HD 5388 b is a 69 M_Jupcompanion instead of a planet

Abstract

We examined six exoplanet host stars with non-standard Hipparcos astrometric solution, which may be indicative of unrecognised orbital motion. Using Hipparcos intermediate astrometric data, we detected the astrometric orbit of HD 5388 at a significance level of 99.4% (2.7 σ). HD 5388 is a metal-deficient star and hosts a planet candidate with a minimum mass of 1.96 M J discovered in 2010. We determined its orbit inclination to be i = 178.3 +0.4 • −0.7 and the corresponding mass of its companion HD 5388 b to be M 2 = 69 ± 20 M J . The orbit is seen almost face-on and the companion mass lies at the upper end of the brown-dwarf mass range. A mass lower than 13 M J was excluded at the 3 σ-level. The astrometric motions of the five other stars had been investigated by other authors revealing two planetary companions, one stellar companion, and two statistically insignificant orbits. We conclude that HD 5388 b is not a planet but most likely a brown-dwarf companion. In addition, we find that the inclinations of the stellar rotation axis and the companion's orbital axis differ significantly.

The Dynamical Mass and Three-Dimensional Orbit of Hr7672b: A Benchmark Brown Dwarf With High Eccentricity

“…Many other dynamical measurements have targeted companions to M-stars, thus helping to circumvent issues with contrast (Zapatero Osorio et al 2004;Ireland et al 2008;Dupuy et al 2009b;Konopacky et al 2010), but M-star metallicities are notoriously difficult to determine (Johnson & Apps 2009). Low-mass companions to solar-type stars have also been studied using Doppler measurements in combination with Hubble Space Telescope astrometry (Benedict et al 2010) and Hipparcos intermediate astrometry (Sahlmann et al 2011), but indirect observations preclude a comparison between spectral models and dynamical mass measurements by definition. One comparable system, HD130948BC, consists of a double brown dwarf orbiting a G2V primary.…”

Enabling science with Gaia observations of naked-eye stars

“…The deduced planet masses are therefore uncertain due to the unknown orbital inclination, named the sin i ambiguity. Astrometric measurements of the stellar barycentric orbit can determine the orbit's inclination accurately and remove the mass ambiguity, [5][6][7][8] thereby leading to a better determination of the planet mass distribution. Because 5 of the 7 parameters describing the orbit are known from RV, the astrometric orbit detection is eased.…”

Planets transiting non-eclipsing binaries

“…Several techniques have been developed to measure the spin-orbit angle: spectroscopically, via the RossiterMcLaughlin effect (Holt 1893;Rossiter 1924;McLaughlin 1924;Queloz et al 2000;Gaudi & Winn 2007;Boué et al 2013) and the Doppler shadow ; statistically (Schlaufman 2010); photometrically thanks to gravity darkening (Szabó et al 2011) or through spot-crossing events (Nutzman et al 2011;Sanchis-Ojeda et al 2012); astrometrically (Sahlmann et al 2011); using asteroseismologic mode splitting (Chaplin et al 2013); or interferometrically (Le Bouquin et al 2009). Searching for transits on non-eclipsing binaries would become another way to detect inclined orbits by spatially resolving the misalignment.…”