“…In this model, hydrocarbons adsorbed on the metal nanoparticle are catalytically decomposed resulting in atomic carbon dissolving into the liquid catalyst particle, and when a supersaturated state is reached, carbon precipitates in a tubular, crystalline form. Recently, several groups have reported successful growth of CNTs from noble metal (Lee et al, 2005;Takagi et al, 2006;Yoshihara et al, 2008;Yuan et al, 2008;Zhou et al, 2006), ceramic (Liu et al, 2008b;Steiner et al, 2009) and semiconducting nanoparticles (Takagi et al, 2007;Uchino et al, 2009;2005b), all of which are regarded as unable to catalyse the dissociation of hydrocarbons. In addition to this, in their bulk form, these materials do not have a catalytic function to produce graphite.…”