Governance factors affecting internal auditors' ethical decision‐making

Abstract

PurposeThe purpose of this paper is to explore the ethical decision making of internal auditors and the impact of corporate governance mechanisms thereon. It also aims to explore whether ethical decision making is influenced by years of experience in internal auditing.Design/methodology/approachA total of 66 internal auditors were presented with five ethical dilemmas. For each scenario, a key element of corporate governance was manipulated to assess its impact on ethical decision making. These were audit committee support; management integrity regarding accounting policies; management integrity regarding pressure on internal audit; external auditor characteristics; and organisational code of conduct.FindingsParticipants were generally sensitive to ethical dilemmas but were not always confident that their peers would act ethically. A higher quality external audit function was positively associated with internal auditors' ethical decision making. However, the strength of other governance mechanisms did not appear to influence ethical decision making. Finally, more experienced internal auditors adopted a more ethical stance in some cases.Research limitations/implicationsThe sample was self‐selected and may not be representative of internal auditors in general. The lack of significant results may be due to insufficient variability in the manipulations and/or an oversimplification of reality in our scenarios.Practical implicationsThe study has implications for the internal audit profession with respect to training and the provision of support mechanisms to strengthen the ability of internal auditors to withstand pressure when dealing with ethical dilemmas.Originality/valueThis paper is the first to study whether the strength of other governance mechanisms influences internal auditors' ethical decision making.

The Role of Individual Variables, Organizational Variables and Moral Intensity Dimensions in Libyan Management Accountants’ Ethical Decision Making

“…Nevertheless, recent studies (e.g. Fang and Foucart 2013;O'Leary and Stewart 2007;Pierce and Sweeney 2010;Valentine and Bateman 2011) generally indicate a positive relationship between work experience and ethical decision making, consistent with Kohlberg's (1969) theory and Treviño's (1986) argument. Thus, this study hypothesizes:…”

“…Nill and Schibrowsky 2005;Roozen et al 2001). O'Leary and Stewart (2007) found little evidence of the possible impact of work experience but argued that the direction of the relationship is still ambiguous. In their review, O'Fallon and Butterfield (2005) conclude that the relationship between work experience and ethical decision making was inconsistent.…”

“…Some of that research has examined the ethical reasoning, moral development and ethical decision-making processes of accounting students and, to some extent, practising accountants, investigating the variables that might influence their decisions (e.g. Buchan 2005;Etherington and Schulting 1995;Johl et al 2012;Marques and Azevedo-Pereira 2009;O'Leary and Stewart 2007;Svanberg 2011).…”

The Mediating Role of Corporate Governance on Intellectual Capital and Corporate Performance

“…As stated in [12], [13], corporate governance is about how a company is directed and controlled to carry out their business activities in order to achieve good performance. It is also how a company conducts its business in a proper and acceptable manner to pull higher confidence in the marketplace thus fulfill society"s expectations on good corporate governance.…”

The Influence of Knowledge, Skills, Attitude and Organization Commitment Using Ethical Climate as A Moderator Towards Ethical Decision Making of Accountants in Malaysia: A Conceptual Paper

“…Much research has been conducted on ethical decisions in the context of business. Some research has examined ethical decision making of accounting students and practising accountants, investigating their variable that might influence their decisions [2,3,4,5]. The role of ethical decision making is important as individuals in an organisations encounter ethical challenges which requires them to engage in decision making process [6].…”