Global Sensitivity Analysis in Life-Cycle Assessment of Early-Stage Technology using Detailed Process Simulation: Application to Dialkylimidazolium Ionic Liquid Production

Abstract

The ability to assess the environmental performance of early-stage technologies at production scale is critical for sustainable process development. This paper presents a systematic methodology for uncertainty quantification in life-cycle assessment (LCA) of such technologies using global sensitivity analysis (GSA) coupled with a detailed process simulator and LCA database. This methodology accounts for uncertainty in both the background and foreground lifecycle inventories, and is enabled by lumping multiple background flows, either downstream or upstream of the foreground processes, in order to reduce the number of factors in the sensitivity analysis. A case study comparing the life-cycle impacts of two dialkylimidazolium ionic liquids is conducted to illustrate the methodology. Failure to account for the foreground process uncertainty alongside the background uncertainty is shown to underestimate the predicted variance of the end-point environmental impacts by a factor of two. Variance-based GSA furthermore reveals that only few foreground and background uncertain parameters contribute significantly to the total variance in the end-point environmental impacts. As well as emphasizing the need to account for foreground uncertainties in LCA of early-stage technologies, these results illustrate how GSA can empower more reliable decision-making in LCA.

Comparative techno-economic and life-cycle analysis of precious versus non-precious metal electrocatalysts: the case of PEM fuel cell cathodes

“…Of the multiple sources of uncertainty that can affect the calculations, we focused on uncertainty in foreground inventory data since we derived the Fe-N-C process inventories from scaled-up lab procedures. 55 We also defined a range of catalyst scenarios to account for future technological advances, with a view to reducing catalyst loading and raw material use and improving production processes. Uncertainty quantification.…”

Accounting for product recovery potential in building life cycle assessments: a disassembly network-based approach

“…In essence, sensitivity analysis investigates the effect of changes in individual parameters on the overall LCA outcomes, for example by employing the one-at-a-time (OAT) method. Here, one parameter is adjusted while others are held constant to understand the distinct influence of that particular parameter (Baaqel et al 2023). On the other hand, robustness analysis evaluates the consistency of the primary findings across various scenarios.…”

Environmental Impact Assessment of Chemical Mechanical Planarization Consumables: Challenges, Future Needs, and Perspectives

“…The subsequent phase involves an Impact Assessment using the Parametric Inventory Method proposed by Padey et al This method, superior to traditional impact assessment techniques, uses a lca_algebraic library with advanced statistics and efficiently conducts extensive Monte Carlo simulations . It offers a nuanced understanding of environmental impact variations and the significance of each parameter. − This methodology examines the environmental implications of different materials used in the manufacturing process. As shown in Figure , Material 1 displays a lower carbon footprint than Material 2.…”