Global Environmental Encounters in Southwest China: Fleeting Intersections and “Transnational Work”

Abstract

This paper engages with the critical literature on development through a study of transnational environmentalism in China. Within the last decade, international development efforts have become increasingly important in shaping China's encounters with global sensibilities, funds, and projects. The author builds on scholarship that approaches China as a transnational entity and examines the emerging politics of the environment in China. Based on an ethnographic case study of a conservation and development project in Yunnan Province, the paper argues against conceptions that international development agendas can be unilaterally imposed. Rather, it suggests that in order to gain traction, agendas require a variety of agents. These agents create convergences through forms of “transnational work,” by and through particular social engagements. Finally, this paper reveals how such convergences remain tenuous and fleeting, and can be quickly dissolved when one side or another changes its orientation.

China Talks Climate: A Frame Analysis of Discourses on Climate Change and the Environment in the PRC

“…2 At the same time, the Chinese public has become more aware and more concerned about climate change and other environmental issues, as evidenced by the jump in environmental protests over the last decade. 3 China's vital role in global efforts to combat climate change, especially in view of the rate and scale of China's environmental impacts on natural ecosystems from local to international levels (Weller 2006;Hathaway 2010;Blaikie and Muldavin 2004), creates a pressing challenge to explore the unique characteristics of Chinese environmental values and policy, as well as the frames that are employed to understand climate change and related environmental issues domestically.…”

“…These works tend to deal with a single case study each time. Many look at a particular group within the population, such as the media (Internews 2013), international environmental NGOs operating in China (Hathaway 2010), or coal miners and mine owners (Hong and Jie 2013). Others focus on a single geographical region, such as the Himalayas (Blaikie and Muldavin 2004) or a township in Inner Mongolia (Hong 2006).…”

Frontiers as dilemma: the incompatible desires for tea production in southwest China

“…Scholars studying southwest China have created a significant body of research to understand the symbolic and material changes in the southwest frontier. Such research, for example, addresses the relationship between the discursive practices of backwardness of economy and cash crop plantation (Sturgeon ), between frontier imaginations and tourism development (Oakes ; Kolås ), and between the natural environment and international NGOs' conservation projects (Litzinger ; Hathaway ). Most of these studies demonstrate that the changing meanings regarding the frontier landscape in southwest China, either its ‘backwardness’ of economy or its ‘primitiveness’ of nature, are more or less related to the late‐socialist state and the market economy of contemporary China.…”

THE EMERGENCE OF INDIGENEITY: Public Intellectuals and an Indigenous Space in Southwest China

“…Pei fostered international interest in Yunnan Province; previously, international conservationists only came to China to protect Panda Bear habitat in neighboring Sichuan Province. Until the mid‐1980s, Yunnan was largely unknown to Western scientists and conservationists (Hathaway in press). In 1990, Pei was a major organizer for the second International Ethnobiology Meeting, likely the largest international conference held in Yunnan Province at the time, bringing hundreds of foreign researchers.…”