Frontiers as dilemma: the incompatible desires for tea production in southwest China

Abstract

In this paper, I argue that frontiers are dilemmas composed of multiple dualities, be they exclusive and inclusive powers, connected space and national periphery, or modernity and primitiveness. These dilemmas, in consequence, become the mechanism to create a leeway for the state to 'tailor' different meanings of frontier to meet the contingent market demands. I use tea production on China's southwest frontier as an example to demonstrate that dilemma is not an end result, but a mechanism to rearticulate the relationship among frontier, the state and the market economy. Specifically, I argue that dilemmas on China's southwest frontier have been forged by the Chinese state with its incompatible desires between 'modernisation' and 'primitiveness' of the tea landscapes in Yunnan, a province on China's southwest frontier. Meanwhile, the incompatible desires and the resulting dilemmas on China's southwest frontier have further mobilised the state to flexibly rework its power to reconstruct the frontier to meet contingent market demand. Based on the shifting meanings of tea landscapes, the state has flexibly 'shuttled through' the dilemmas between development of modernisation and preservation of primitiveness on the frontier.

Amazon's dead ends: Frontier-making the centre

“…The government championed national development and integration plans (financed largely from multilateral loans fuelled by petrodollars) that triggered internal migration of farmers and fostered new rounds of primitive accumulation by private companies entitled to receive generous subsidies once they started operating in the Amazon. This is related to the claim by Hung (2014) that frontiers are based on simultaneous dualities (e.g. inclusion/exclusion, periphery/connection, modernity/primitiveness) that constitute essential dilemmas through which the state can 'tailor' different meanings to meet contingent market demands.…”

Riverfront as a re-territorialising arena of urban governance: Territorialisation and folding of the Xindian River in Taipei metropolis

“…A border is therefore also a frontier where human societies confront the relatively ‘raw’ wilderness. The maintenance, advancement or retreat of such a frontier are moments when human beings rearrange material objects to readjust the border defining the state, region or city so as to secure control of the resource (Rasmussen and Lund, 2018), to manifest political legitimacy (Howitt, 2001) or to open up new ground for economic development (Hung, 2014).…”