Gender disparity in leadership boosts affective commitment and tacit knowledge sharing about libraries

Abstract

Purpose This study aims to use an authentic leadership style to explore that whether male or female leadership of private academic institutions highly influences affective organizational commitment and tacit knowledge sharing among the library teachers. Additionally, this study encompasses the trust of library teachers and justifies whether the trust under male or female leadership highly moderates the effect on tacit knowledge sharing. Design/methodology/approach By using structural equation modeling, this study tests two leadership models (e.g. male and female leadership models). Using a convenient sampling approach, the researcher collects data from library teachers of private academic institutions in district Sheikhupura, Pakistan through face-to-face interaction. The study administered 650 survey questionnaires among the library teachers; however, 403 questionnaires were answered validly and reliably. The response rate was 62%. Findings The study found the direct and indirect effect of authentic leadership on affective organizational commitment and tacit knowledge sharing however, male authentic leadership influence on affective organizational commitment and tacit knowledge sharing was quite higher than female authentic leadership. Resultantly, the library teachers were more committed to sharing tacit knowledge under male leadership than female. Nevertheless, the moderating role of trust was found in female leadership but not in male leadership. Simply, the library teachers under male leadership were hesitant to trust others, so the chain of sharing hidden ideas and image of libraries was not found in male leadership. Practical implications Private academic institutions need authentic leaders to shape the knowledge economy of libraries and the structure of the academic institutions. For this reason, this study provides practical implications for managers that male leadership should be hired in academic institutions because it has a higher influence on librarians’ commitment and tacit knowledge sharing among peers as compare to female leadership. Originality/value To the best of the authors’ knowledge, this was the first study that differentiates the capabilities and skills of male and female authentic leadership in private academic institutions. Further, it suggests hiring male leaders in these institutions.

Leadership Style and Employees' Commitment to Service Quality: An Analysis of the Mediation Pathway via Knowledge Sharing

“…Our result explained that the leader's role in sharing knowledge with employees enhances their commitment and encourages them to participate in decision-making processes. Our results are consistent with the arguments of Iqbal et al ( 2018 ), Mohammed and Kamalanabhan ( 2020 ), and Sharif et al ( 2021 ) which state participative leadership can increase involvement and commitment among employees through information sharing. These results explain that frontline employees' participation in decision-making is clearly linked to ownership and commitment of employees and stimulates positive attitudes and behavior toward quality service delivery.…”

“…Our result explained that the leader's role in sharing knowledge with employees enhances their commitment and encourages them to participate in decision-making processes. Our results are consistent with the arguments of Iqbal et al (2018), Mohammed andKamalanabhan (2020), andSharif et al (2021) which state participative leadership can increase involvement and commitment among employees through information sharing.…”

Impact of Ethical Leadership on Creative Work Performance: The Empirical Mediating Roles of Work Engagement and Attitude Toward Performing Wells in Construction Organizations in Pakistan

“…Ethical leadership also boosts workplace creativity with job engagement (Ferrell et al 2021, Buonomo et al 2021, Sharif et al 2021, Wibawa et al 2021. Italian and Pakistani employees seemed more engaged and well under ethical leadership (Sarwar et al 2020).…”

“…,(Saddique et al 2021). The questionnaires were given to people who worked at different construction companies in Lahore.…”

Effects of organizational culture, affective commitment and trust on knowledge-sharing tendency

“…In a more recent study, Lo and Tian (2020) suggested that the propensity to share knowledge is driven not only by organizational factors such as OC, but also individualized factors. Further support proposed by Sharif et al (2021) indicates the tendency to share knowledge is based on individual factors such as affective organizational commitment and trust. Hislop (2003), Perotti et al (2022), Ro et al (2020) and Than et al (2021) suggest that committed employees tend to share their knowledge with co-workers.…”