One sentence summary:238 U/ 235 U ratios for U-bearing accessory minerals from a diverse suite of terrestrial rocks indicate a >5‰ range with an average zircon value of 238 U/ 235 U = 137.818 ± 0.045 (2σ) which is consistent with the composition of other terrestrial and meteoritic reservoirs. 2, 3). However, a robust λ 235 U can only be determined with U-Pb analyses using a tracer calibration that is traceable to SI units and free of other potential sources of bias, so we refrain from suggesting this value be adopted at present and urge caution in abandoning the Jaffey et al (1) λ 235 U determination until such a dataset has been generated and evaluated.An emerging 238 U/ 235 U dataset for a wide range of rocks, minerals, and meteorites is now available (17,18,25,(30)(31)(32)(33) and compiled here (Fig. 3)