Elucidation of biomolecular interactions is of utmost importance in biochemistry. Photo-cross-linking offers the possibility to precisely determine RNA-protein interactions. However, despite the inherent specificity of enzymes, approaches for site-specific introduction of photo-cross-linking moieties into nucleic acids are scarce. Methyltransferases in combination with synthetic analogues of their natural cosubstrate S-adenosyl-l-methionine (AdoMet) allow for the post-synthetic site-specific modification of biomolecules. We report on three novel AdoMet analogues bearing the most widespread photo-cross-linking moieties (aryl azide, diazirine, and benzophenone). We show that these photo-cross-linkers can be enzymatically transferred to the methyltransferase target, that is, the mRNA cap, with high efficiency. Photo-cross-linking of the resulting modified mRNAs with the cap interacting protein eIF4E was successful with aryl azide and diazirine but not benzophenone, reflecting the affinity of the modified 5' caps.