From punishment to prevention: A French case study of the introduction of co-regulation in enforcing food safety

Abstract

International audienceIn the last decade, the concept of co-regulation has been developed and increasingly promoted as an important instrument of regulation. In the context of food safety, we examine co-regulation programs from the point of view of an enforcement agency. We develop a conceptual framework of enforcement of food safety regulation for use in assessing the degree of shift toward co-regulation from traditional approaches and apply it to a case study of the French import market for produce at Perpignan. We find that co-regulation in the enforcement of pesticide residue limits resulted in a change of practices for the regulatory agency from punishment to prevention based on incentives and information programs

Public Private Partnerships in food industries: A road to success?

“…In the context of developing countries, Narrod et al (2009) In the food safety literature, scholars mostly consider these arrangements as the result of a regulatory change (GarciaMartinez et al, 2007;Rouvière and Caswell, 2012;Verbruggen and Havinga, 2014). In this perspective, these programmes are implemented as regulatory tools in order to enforce newly designed food safety standards or traceability systems (GarciaMartinez et al, 2007(GarciaMartinez et al, , 2013Rouvière and Caswell, 2012). The newly developed systems are considered as private strategies to regulatory changes.…”

“…Regulations are considered as institutions or the rules of the game, as defined by North (1994). There is a consensus that the collaboration between public and private agents is located somewhere in-between command and control intervention, and self-regulation (Garcia-Martinez et al, 2007;Ogus, 2000;Rouvière and Caswell, 2012). Moreover, Garcia-Martinez et al (2013) underline that collaborative arrangements can be established at different phases of the regulatory process.…”

A Study of Comprehensive Support Measures for Food Safety Governance in China

“…Makiko Matsuo (2013) affirmed the effectiveness of the government's governance by illustrating the implement of the Consumer Protection Act, the establishment of the Consumer Affairs Bureau (CAA) and the foundation of the Food Safety Commission of Japan (FSC) for dealing with the crisis of the "mad cow disease" since 2000 [4]. Yang (2012) drew a conclusion that the settlement of food safety issue depended on clearing the important work of food safety governance and strengthening restrictions on enterprises after making comparisons between the dilemma of food safety governance with and without government supervision [5].…”

Retail Driven Food Safety Regulation

“…What will be the responsibility of public authorities participating in hybrid or private types of food governance? National food authorities in countries such as the UK, the Netherlands and Canada are discussing how they should and could take private certification into account (Canadian Food Inspection Agency 2012; Rouvière and Caswell 2012;Wright et al 2013).…”