“…Numerous laboratory studies have investigated the ice nucleation ability of soot (e.g., Garten and Head, 1964;De-Mott, 1990;Diehl and Mitra, 1998;Gorbunov et al, 1998;DeMott et al, 1999;Gorbunov et al, 2001;Suzanne et al, 2003;Popovicheva et al, 2004;Möhler et al, 2005a, b;Dymarska et al, 2006;Kanji and Abbatt, 2006;DeMott et al, 2009;Fornea et al, 2009;Koehler et al, 2009;Kanji et al, 2011;Crawford et al, 2011;Chou et al, 2013;Brooks et al, 2014;Kulkarni et al, 2016;Schill et al, 2016;Charnawskas et al, 2017;Demirdjian et al, 2009;Kireeva et al, 2009;HĂ€usler et al, 2018) and a review was recently provided by Ullrich et al (2017). However, these studies have revealed a large variability in ice nucleation characteristics of soot particles, indicating that the ice formation ability of soot remains poorly understood.…”