Freedom of Association in Vietnam: A Heretical View

Abstract

Vietnam is a one-party state with a single state-led union federation and significant numbers of wildcat strikes. In January 2021, independent worker representative organisations became legal. The reforms are creating significant excitement among labour watchers and practitioners. This article, however, provides a more sceptical tone. Drawing on Atzeni’s critique of trade union fetishism, I argue that, rather than being a progressive step forward, freedom of association reforms are an attempt to reduce labour militancy. First, Vietnam is implementing reforms while further embedding itself into neo-liberal capital flows and global production networks – the very form of capitalism that undermined trade unionism elsewhere. Second, workers have been using effective forms of self-organised, wildcat militancy for two decades, which has led to significant improvements in terms of wages, conditions and national policy. The current organisational form of wildcat strikes does not easily fit into a worker representative organisation (WRO) structure. Third, because existing forms of resistance have worked, workers have not been demanding independent organisations. Rather, such demands have come from capital. Previous attempts to build harmonious labour relations by reducing militancy through incorporating class antagonisms into non-threatening forms have failed. Consequently, capital has now embraced ideas around freedom of association as an attempt to tame worker resistance. KEYWORDS: Strikes; unions; freedom of association; Vietnam; WROs

Individual Labor Dispositione: Comparative Research Between Labour Law of Vietnam and Singapore

“…However, it is learned that they have never given any notice about the strike. On the other hand, Vietnam's participation with the "World Trade Organization" position a lot of pressure on the country's government to include some provisions consistent with the criteria of the "International Labour Organization" (Buckley, 2021).…”

The internal organisation of employees in the enterprise in Vietnam - regulations and recommendations

“…From the national level down, trade unions are free to participate in political and policy debates and deliberations. The internal employee organizations in an enterprise, on the other hand, are unable to participate in such debates and discussions outside of their own company 6 . So far, that is, the grassroots-level Trade union is the lowest level, the upper level also has the local industry union, the district-level Labor Confedera-tion… and the highest level is the Vietnam General Confederation of Labor.…”

‘A Force for Good’: The Narrative Construction of Ethical EU–Vietnam Trade Relations

“…In both the FTA and VPA agreements, ethical problems are narrated so that they do not conflict with the logic of free trade: they are simplified as manageable rule‐related problems. The ‘goodness’ of trade relies on the fixing of these rule‐related problems through the implementation of the right international agreements (FTA) or the establishment of the right infrastructure (VPA) (see also Buckley, 2021). The importance of dialogue to achieve the desired rules is emphasized.…”