Freedom of association in the case law of the European Court of Human Rights

Golubović, Dragan

doi:10.1080/13642987.2013.835307

Cited by 4 publications

(2 citation statements)

References 0 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…However, it is neither unthinkable nor unknown that an ambitious party might conceal its political agenda until it comes into power. 93 In this regard, 'the acts and positions of the members and leaders' of the party in question should be taken account of, 94 in order to examine whether or not the potential danger can be identified. For instance, in the case of Refah Partisi and Others v. Turkey, the Court concluded that the party's real intentions were contrary to democratic principles, based on the reading of relevant speeches delivered by its leaders and members.…”

Section: Cases Involving Political Organizationsmentioning

confidence: 99%

The ECtHR’s suitability test in national security cases: Two models for balancing human rights and national security

Jing¹

2023

Leiden Journal of International Law

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

The European Court of Human Rights has often been criticized for lacking clarity and consistency in its reasoning of balancing human rights against conflicting public interests. To reconcile national security with human rights protection, the Court requires the interference with rights to be suitable for reaching the objective purported by the government. In this article I deal with how the Court conducts the suitability test in national security cases, in line with two models under which a few representative test considerations can be categorized: human rights priority model and national security priority model. To explain how each model works in a comparable sense, I follow the same analytic structure and examine the manner of the Court’s test and the intensity of its scrutiny. I argue that in compliance with the two models, the Court applies the suitability test in a consistent and predictable way in national security case law.

show abstract

Section: Cases Involving Political Organizationsmentioning

confidence: 99%

The ECtHR’s suitability test in national security cases: Two models for balancing human rights and national security

Jing¹

2023

Leiden Journal of International Law

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…However, the Court also agrees that it is neither unthinkable nor unknown that an ambitious party might conceal its political agenda until it comes to power. 577 In this regard, 'the acts and positions of the members and leaders' of the party in question should be taken into account 578 in order to examine whether a potential danger can be identified. In, for instance, Refah Partisi and Others v. Turkey, the Court concluded that the party's real intentions were contrary to democratic principles, based on the reading of relevant speeches given by its leaders and members.…”

Section: Suitability Testmentioning

confidence: 99%

The Impact of National Security on Human Rights

JING

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Is national security the Achilles’ heel of the discourse on human rights protections? The thesis studies how national security and human rights interact with each other in Europe and China, and how each actor seeks to protect one without damaging the substance of the other. This thesis argues that the European Court of Human Rights’ reasoning in its national security case law can be read in a consistent and predictable way. On the one hand, depending on the nature of the rights involved, the Court prioritises human rights over national security in some cases, and vice versa in others. On the other hand, the Court attempts to redress this tendency by weighing the concrete facts and specific circumstances of each case. When it comes to China, the thesis first notes that it shares similar perceptions of national security and civil and political rights with Europe. Further, the thesis argues that China normally views national security outweighing human rights. By comparing the approaches taken by Europe and China, the thesis finds that both parties tend to allow the government authorities to take proactive actions against national security threats, even those threats may be potential, distant or cumulative. Nevertheless, divergences are found in how the two parties unfold their approaches. It is noted that the approach taken by China is short of an effective arrangement against abuse of power by the government authorities. In this context, the thesis proposes the areas that China can work on.

show abstract

Pregled Prakse Evropskog Suda Za Ljudska Prava Od Značaja Za Obradu Podataka O Ličnosti Putem Video-Nadzora

Golubović,

Galetin

2024

SPZ

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Ubrzani razvoj novih tehnologija, uključujući i veštačku inteligenciju, koje se koriste u cilju obrade podataka o ličnosti predstavlja sve veći izazov za zakonodavca kada je reč o zaštiti prava na privatnost zajemčenog čl. 8, st. 1 Evropske konvencije, ali i čl. 42 Ustava Republike Srbije kojim se explicite jemči pravo na zaštitu podataka o ličnosti. S tim u vezi, standardi uspostavljeni odlukama Evropskog suda za ljudska prava u tumačenju obima i sadržine prava na privatnost i drugih prava i sloboda zajemčenih Konvencijom sastavni su deo unutrašnjeg pravnog poretka Republike Srbije. Ovi su standardi od posebnog značaja, imajuću u vidu da obrada podataka o ličnosti putem video-nadzora u našem pravu nije izričito uređena. U radu je predstavljena praksa Evropskog suda za ljudska prava koja obuhvata ključna pitanja od značaja za obradu podataka o ličnosti putem video-nadzora, u svetlu standarda koje Sud primenjuje za ocenu legitimnog ograničenja prava na privatnost i drugih relativnih prava, uključujući i nedavnu presudu u kojoj se Sud prvi put izjašnjavao o obradi podataka o ličnosti putem video-nadzora sa opcijom prepoznavanja lica.

show abstract

Freedom of association in the case law of the European Court of Human Rights

Cited by 4 publications

References 0 publications

The ECtHR’s suitability test in national security cases: Two models for balancing human rights and national security

The ECtHR’s suitability test in national security cases: Two models for balancing human rights and national security

The Impact of National Security on Human Rights

Pregled Prakse Evropskog Suda Za Ljudska Prava Od Značaja Za Obradu Podataka O Ličnosti Putem Video-Nadzora

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About