Forty Years of Social Mobility in France: Change in Social Fluidity in the Light of Recent Models

Abstract

The aim of this paper is to examine whether a long-term trend can be identified in the mobility regime of French society from the middle of the century. It begins with a review of the international literature on temporal trends in social fluidity within modern societies. Analysing recent French research which has concluded that inequality of opportunity has remained unchanged in France during the last two decades, the paper argues that such a conclusion can only have resulted from the use of insufficiently powerful statistical techniques. The second part of the paper analyses father-son and father-daughter mobility tables drawn from national representative surveys carried out in 1953, 1970, 1977, 1985 and 1993 (N=35,741 for males and 18,484 for females). The use of log-linear and log-multiplicative models reveals that the statistical association (as measured with the logarithm of the odds ratio) between social origin and destination has declined steadily by 0.5 % a year over a period of forty years. This finding highlights a slow but continuous trend towards a reduction in inequality of opportunity from the middle of the century. Of the twelve million French men and women between the ages of 35 and 59 who were in employment in 1993, nearly half a million would have belonged to different classes without this forty year increase in social fluidity. The paper concludes that the thesis of temporal invariance in the intergenera-tional mobility regime cannot be maintained for France, but that the reasons of this change still remain to be ascertained.

What we have learned: RC28's contributions to knowledge about social stratification

“…It was shifted to a conceptual contribution so we will explain the meaning of MMI in the next section. Here we just note that the American case does not fit MMI (Hout, Raftery, and Bell 1993;Lucas 2001), and the Netherlands, Sweden, and France show evidence of declining class barriers even though the advantaged classes have not reached "saturation" (Ganzeboom and Nieuwbeerta 1996;Jonsson and Mills 1993;Vallet 2001) -negating a key element of MMI.…”

Social mobility and musical tastes: A reappraisal of the social meaning of taste eclecticism

“…the intrinsic strength of the association between sons' (daughters') occupation and fathers' occupation (Erikson & Goldthorpe, 1992). More recent studies concluded that the statistical association between social origin and destination has declined steadily since the end of World War II in France, though (Vallet, 2001). In that domain, the main characteristic of France, compared with many similar countries, is that school expansion has been relatively belated, with a dramatic increase in the number of secondary school graduates between 1985 and 1995, which has had a rather small and unclear impact on the reduction of inequalities in educational opportunities (Duru-Bellat & Kieffer, 2000;Duru-Bellat, 2008).…”

Accounting for structural and exchange mobility in models of status attainment: Social fluidity in five European countries

“…There are also cohort analyses in single countries assessing the effect of industrialization, educational expansion, market liberalization, and rising inequalities on mobility (Ishida 2001;Vallet 2001;Goldthorpe and Mills 2008). When combined, the two approaches have led to investigating the hypothesis of a secular convergence towards more fluidity driven by industrialization and post-industrialism.…”