Foreign direct investment and gendered wages in urban China

Abstract

This paper documents the changing impact of foreign direct investment (FDI) on gendered wages in urban China. Combining household survey data from 1995 and 2002 with province-level macro-data, the paper finds that FDI as a proportion of investment has a sizable and statistically significant positive effect on both female and male wages in both years. In 1995, women experienced larger gains from FDI than men, but those gender-based advantages had reversed by 2002, with men experiencing larger wage gains from FDI than women. The paper argues that these results reflect the shift of foreign-invested enterprises to higher productivity and more domestically oriented production, a shift that interacts with gender-based employment segregation to more greatly advantage workers in male-dominated than female-dominated industries. These findings indicate that FDI can have considerable structural effects on economies that reach beyond the particular workers and firms linked to foreign investors.China, earnings differentials, foreign direct investment, trade liberalization, JEL Codes: F21, J7, O53,

The role ofguanxinetworks in the performance of women-led firms in China

“…Foreign direct investment (FDI) in China has, in the long run, appeared to have provided greater "wage gains" to men than to women (Braunstein and Brenner, 2007). Shu et al (2007) found gender differentials in FDI employment, with women concentrated in lower-paid "export-oriented manufacturing industries" rather than "high-paying foreign firms and joint ventures".…”

“…However, although almost as many women as men work in China, for some this is by necessity due to low wages. Furthermore, there is low representation in more senior roles often due to opaque promotional procedures (Cooke, 2001(Cooke, , 2004(Cooke, , 2005(Cooke, , 2008bCatalyst, 2008), compounded by poor job mobility prospects (Cao and Hu, 2007), occupational segregation (Cai and Wu, 2006), work and pay inequalities particularly for married women with children and for those working in externally owned, FDI-funded plants (Braunstein and Brenner, 2007;Shu et al, 2007), and in particular for women migrant workers (Feng and Anan, 2003;Liang and Chen, 2003;Ngai, 2004;Tam, 2008). The "bamboo curtain" (Tan, 2008) and the economic opportunities now open to many women (Cooke, 2005) have influenced the creation of many new ventures that are women-led.…”

Global Gender and Environment Outlook 2016

“…Both women and men may benefit from increased economic opportunities, but because women are universally paid less than men and their labor is more contingent they typically gain less than do their male counterparts. A recent analysis of women and men working in foreign export manufacturing zones in China, for example, found that women received smaller wage gains compared to men (Braunstein and Brenner 2007). Secondly, pre-existing gender inequality is often used intentionally to attract foreign investment and economic growth and, in some cases, might be a prerequisite for it (Seguino 2000).…”

Technological upgrading and decent work in the manufacturing sector: evidence from seven coastline provinces, China, 2002-2014

“…They acknowledge that their independent variables are at different levels of aggregation, which causes a downward bias when estimating regression coefficient standard errors. The issue has been addressed by estimating standard errors clustered on provinces (Braunstein and Brenner 2007). However, like Braunstein and Epstein (2002), this model does not contain price expectation as one of the independent variables as well, which is a weakness of this model.…”

“…Braunstein and Brenner (2007) combine macroeconomic-level data and microeconomiclevel data, which is the key innovation of their study. They acknowledge that their independent variables are at different levels of aggregation, which causes a downward bias when estimating regression coefficient standard errors.…”