First‐time viewers' comprehension of films: Bridging shot transitions

Abstract

Which perceptual and cognitive prerequisites must be met in order to be able to comprehend a film is still unresolved and a controversial issue. In order to gain some insights into this issue, our field experiment investigates how first-time adult viewers extract and integrate meaningful information across film cuts. Three major types of commonalities between adjacent shots were differentiated, which may help first-time viewers with bridging the shots: pictorial, causal, and conceptual. Twenty first-time, 20 low-experienced and 20 high-experienced viewers from Turkey were shown a set of short film clips containing these three kinds of commonalities. Film clips conformed also to the principles of continuity editing. Analyses of viewers' spontaneous interpretations show that first-time viewers indeed are able to notice basic pictorial (object identity), causal (chains of activity), as well as conceptual (links between gaze direction and object attention) commonalities between shots due to their close relationship with everyday perception and cognition. However, first-time viewers' comprehension of the commonalities is to a large degree fragile, indicating the lack of a basic notion of what constitutes a film.

Anticipatory Eye Movements While Watching Continuous Action Across Shots in Video Sequences: A Developmental Study

“…This awareness is at least partly due to experience with edited film. Ildirar and Schwan (; see also Schwan & Ildirar, ) found that adults who had no experience with edited film were sometimes able to comprehend sequences spontaneously when the sequences depicted familiar actions that unfolded across several shots. However, comprehension was limited: These novice viewers often misinterpreted sequences that depicted visually distinct (albeit semantically related) shots, such as those that depicted different areas of one larger space.…”

What's your neural function, visual narrative conjunction? Grammar, meaning, and fluency in sequential image processing

“…Accordingly, we might expect differences in E-Conjunction processing between manga readers, who likely store these schematic structures as part of their “visual language” fluency, and readers of American comics, for whom such structures are less entrenched. Some role for experience is suggested by findings that naïve film viewers from a remote Turkish village have deficits generating “spatial inferences” from films using sequences akin to E-Conjunction (Ildirar & Schwan, 2015; Schwan & Ildirar, 2010). While this effect of experience held for individuals lacking exposure to visual narratives, we would expect processing differences within experienced comic readers based on which comics they have read.…”

Match-Action: The Role of Motion and Audio in Creating Global Change Blindness in Film

“…When asked to describe what they had seen, first-time viewers were only able to accurately describe edited sequences in which a familiar line of action bridged the cut. In a follow-up study (Ildirar & Schwan, 2015), the authors compared cuts combining shots with different types of relations, such as pictorial (e.g. the same person depicted from two viewpoints), causal (e.g.…”