“…The presented SSCHA calculations included the entropic effects coming from the ionic fluctuations only, with the electrons kept at 0 K. The good agreement between the experiments and the T CDW obtained with the SSCHA, compared to the extremely high T CDW found at harmonic level (which, on the contrary, included only the electronic fluctuations), suggests that the ionic fluctuations play the dominant role in suppressing the CDW order. However, since in bulk and monolayer NbSe 2 the electronic density of states at the Fermi level is quite sizeable [39,56], mainly due to localized d states, the electronic contribution to entropy is not guaranteed to be negligible when anharmonicty is taken into account. In order to carefully estimate the electronic contribution to the fluctuations also at the anharmonic level, so as to give a quantitative comparison between the ionic and electronic thermal effects, we perform SSCHA calculations including finite-temperature electronic fluctuations.…”