“…Dating of subaerial sediments outcropping in the Lower Volga and assigned to the Atelian, provided ages between 80.0 and 28.0 kyr using TL method (Shahovets, 1987, while by OSL they are between ca 70.0 and 19.0 kyr (Kurbanov et al, 2020;Költringer et al, 2020). Calibrated radiocarbon dates from Northern Caspian Sea basin where Atelian sediments have been identified in seismicacoustic profiles and sediment cores, ranged from ca 44.4 to 39.3 cal kyr BP (Svitoch et al, 2008b;Bezrodnykh et al, 2017;Yanina et al, 2018Yanina et al, , 2020. proposed the Atelian lowstand occurred between ca 75.0 and 40.0 cal kyr BP and considered younger sediments from the Lower Volga as no more representing the Atelian period, while Lavrushin and colleagues (2014) have recognised two stages: (i) an old and long-lasting palaeoAtelian between ca 130.0 and 60.0 kyr, and (ii) a short-term event at ca 20.0 cal kyr BP.…”