Well-established
techniques, e.g., chromatography and capillary
electrophoresis, are available for separating nanosized particles,
such as proteins. However, similar techniques for separating micron-sized
particles are still needed. Insulator-based electrokinetic (iEK) systems
can achieve efficient microparticle separations by combining linear
and nonlinear EK phenomena. Of particular interest are charge-based
separations, which could be employed for separating similar microorganisms,
such as bacterial cells of the same size, same genus, or same strain.
Several groups have reported charge-based separations of microparticles
where a zeta potential difference of at least 40 mV between the microparticles
was required. The present work pushes the limit of the discriminatory
capabilities of iEK systems by reporting the charged-based separation
of two microparticles of the same size (5.1 μm), same shape,
same substrate material, and with a small difference in particle
zeta potentials of only 3.6 mV, which is less than 10% of the difference
in previous studies. By building an accurate COMSOL Multiphysics model, which correctly accounts for dielectrophoresis and electrophoresis
of the second kind, it was possible to identify the conditions to
achieve this challenging separation. Furthermore, the COMSOL model
allowed predicting particle retention times (t
R,p) which were compared with experimental
values (t
R,e). The separations
results had excellent reproducibility in terms of t
R,e with variations of only 9% and 11% between repetitions.
These findings demonstrate that, by following a robust protocol that
involves modeling and experimental work, it is possible to discriminate
between highly similar particles, with much smaller differences in
electrical charge than previously reported.