Financial Management Reforms in the Health Sector: A Comparative Study Between Cash-based and Accrual-based Accounting Systems

Abstract

Background:Financial management and accounting reform in the public sectors was started in 2000. Moving from cash-based to accrual-based is considered as the key component of these reforms and adjustments in the public sector. Performing this reform in the health system is a part of a bigger reform under the new public management.Objectives:The current study aimed to analyze the movement from cash-based to accrual-based accounting in the health sector in Iran.Patients and Methods:This comparative study was conducted in 2013 to compare financial management and movement from cash-based to accrual-based accounting in health sector in the countries such as the United States, Britain, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, and Iran. Library resources and reputable databases such as Medline, Elsevier, Index Copernicus, DOAJ, EBSCO-CINAHL and SID, and Iranmedex were searched. Fish cards were used to collect the data. Data were compared and analyzed using comparative tables.Results:Developed countries have implemented accrual-based accounting and utilized the valid, reliable and practical information in accrual-based reporting in different areas such as price and tariffs setting, operational budgeting, public accounting, performance evaluation and comparison and evidence based decision making. In Iran, however, only a few public organizations such as the municipalities and the universities of medical sciences use accrual-based accounting, but despite what is required by law, the other public organizations do not use accrual-based accounting.Conclusions:There are advantages in applying accrual-based accounting in the public sector which certainly depends on how this system is implemented in the sector.

Public Hospital Facilities Development Using Build-Operate-Transfer Approach: Policy Consideration for Developing Countries

“…The variables for the comparison were extracted from a review of the literature and included the following: legal framework, legal scope, health sector, policy framework, structural framework, contract framework, and funding procedure (16,17). These variables were validated by the research team and two more experts in the area of PPP.…”

The Households Health Spending and Impoverishment: A Study After Iran's Health Transformation Plan

“…HTP was implemented in May 5, 2014, with 8 service packages (6). The main factors of the reform, which was introduced by experts in the health system are as follows: increasing health care costs, increasing public expectations, resources limitation and increasing public demand from the government due to poor governance, corruption and inefficiency of power, and bureaucratic inhibitors (8,9). Three financial sources are determined for supporting the plan: increasing the public annual budget of health sector, resources of the targeted subsidies' law (10% of total subsidies), and a specific 1% value added tax (VAT) for health.…”

Estimation of economic burden of preterm and premature births in Iran

“…Health systems not only play a critical and important role in improving health, but also are responsible to protect individuals against the financial costs of illnesses and diseases ( 13 ). Regarding the fact that financial management is one of the basic principles in the health sector, providing and managing financial resources is critical ( 14 ). Studies have shown increases in hospitalization costs during the first year of life for the infants suffering from some early defects such as bronchopulmonary dysplasia and intraventricular hemorrhage ( 15 , 16 ).…”