Fear vs humor appeals: a comparative study of children's responses to anti-smoking advertisements

Abstract

PurposeThis study aims to examine the different effects that the fear and humor appeals in anti-smoking advertisements for children have on their affective reactions to the advertisements, on their beliefs about smoking and on their behavioral intentions to smoke.Design/methodology/approachThis paper presents the findings of a qualitative research study conducted in Italy with children aged from 8 to 11 years.FindingsThe results indicated that the humor appeal is a useful method for conveying a social theme in a pleasant way and creating a likable character that becomes an example for children to imitate; however, it is necessary to employ the fear appeal to make children reflect carefully about the negative consequences of smoking.Research limitations/implicationsThis study examined only children's behavioral intentions derived from anti-smoking advertisements, but future research should also examine their real behaviors after a period following repeated viewing of public service announcements about smoking prevention or other social issues.Practical implicationsUnderstanding how different types of appeals can influence children represents an important result for the prevention of youth smoking and the promotion of healthy lifestyle habits during childhood.Social implicationsUnderstanding how different types of appeals can influence children represents an important result for the prevention of youth smoking and the promotion of healthy lifestyle habits during childhood.Originality/valueFew studies have examined the impact of social advertisements on children, and particularly little is known about the effectiveness of fear appeals on this group.

Association between anti-smoking campaign types and smoking cessation attempts

“…One study showed that an advertisement depicting an extreme scene is more persuasive than one that shows something fun. ( Nicolini & Cassia, 2021 ). This means that when evaluating the change in social norms through a campaign, the message the campaign is trying to convey should not be evaluated in isolation.…”

Presepsi Remaja Terhadap Gangguan Kecemasan Pada Fase Remaja Akhir Menuju Dewasa Awal

“…Kondisi tersebut terjadi karena minimnya studi yang meneliti tentang hal tersebut. Namun demikian, perkembangan perilaku seseorang dapat dilihat sejak usia anak-anak (Kiili et al, 2021;Nicolini & Cassia, 2022). Kesulitan beradaptasi dalam berprilaku positif pada masa anak-anak akan berdampak negatif dan berkelanjutan.…”

A Study on the Presentation and Communication Influence of Shaanxi Regional Culture in Public Service Advertisements from the Perspective of Social Network Analysis

“…The process of the audience's active participation in the gradual penetration of public welfare concepts so that it forms a stronger public welfare perception, with twoway communication advantages of interactive public service ads for the dissemination of information to open up a more effective way [4]. As the most essential attribute of PSA design, public welfare should be carried out throughout the creation [5][6]. PSAs follow the pace of development of the times in the choice of topics and keep the right and innovation [7].…”