Fear and Violence as Organizational Strategies: The Possibility of a Derridean Lens to Analyze Extra-judicial Police Violence

Abstract

Governments and majoritarian political formations often present police violence as nationalist media spectacles, which marginalize the rights of the accused and normalize the discourse of majoritarian nationalism. In this study, we explore the public discourse of how the State and political actors repeatedly labeled a college-going student Ishrat Jahan, who died in a stage-managed police killing in India in 2004, as a terrorist. We draw from Derrida’s ethics of unconditional hospitality to show that while police violence is aimed at constructing safety for the cultural majority, in reality, it reveals discourses of anxiety and precariousness. The unethicality of police violence lies in the enlargement of recognition in vicariously blaming the person who has been killed for being involved in several terror attacks. We show that police violence is premised on the temporal structure of majoritarian nationalism, the prevalence of gender inequity, and the call to breach the secular framework of law.

How is social inequality maintained in the Global South? Critiquing the concept of dirty work

“…As Douglas (1966 [2002]) argues, “the pollution [becomes] a doubly wicked object of reprobation, first because he crossed the line and second because he endangered others” (as cited in Varman et al, 2021: 648). This is reminiscent of the politics of fear and violence that Jagannathan et al (2022) and Prasad (2020) highlight in their studies of state brutality against Muslims in contemporary India.…”

Rising Violence Against Muslims in India Under Modi and BJP Rule

“…Researchers have shown that Indian security forces "identify with structures of majoritarian nationalism to enact violence. " 32 The 2019 ruling by India's Supreme Court in favor of Hindu nationalists who destroyed the 16 th century Babri Mosque in 1992 is the culmination of BJP's effort to chip away at the rights of Muslims in the judiciary, and thus reaffirming their status as second-class citizens in a supposedly secular democratic country. 33 This rising animosity and violence towards Muslims by the Hindu majority population reached a zenith over six bloody days in New Delhi during February 23-29, 2020, when more than 50 Muslims were murdered after a BJP leader gave a speech urging supporters to attack anti-CAA protesters.…”