How is social inequality maintained in the Global South? Critiquing the concept of dirty work

Abstract

Extant research on dirty work—occupations involving physical, social or moral taint, which affect worker identities—has been read primarily through the lens of social identity theory (SIT). There are two notable shortcomings that emerge as a consequent of dirty work being too heavily reliant upon the precepts of SIT, which we seek to remedy in this article: (1) the overemphasis on the symbolic to the detriment of the material, which has led to false optimism regarding the ability for subjects doing dirty work to exercise agency in constructing their own sense of selves and, (2) the failure to substantively account for the role of identity differences, which suggests that empirical research on the phenomenon is devoid of proper historical and cultural contextualization. Drawing on a qualitive study on low-caste toilet cleaners in Pakistan, our findings were largely incongruous with the scholarly conceptualization of dirty work that has been propagated to date. We explicate the embedded role of power and context in dirty work, which are not adequately considered using SIT alone. Repudiating the overly romanticized version of the concept, we argue that SIT’s account of the concept ought to be complemented by social construction theory going forward.

Faculty's subjective well-being: insights from a Mexican business school

“…Such first-order categories allowed us to find information in the interviews which allowed us to support the relevance of those categories through the iterative reading of the transcripts. Like Zulfiqar and Prasad (2022), we performed an iterative process which involved studying articles related to our topic and our data; performing said iterative process allowed us to organically develop our three main codes. The following section presents our findings based on the categories that we developed: the institutional pressure's effects on health, sense of lack of self-efficacy and the potential apprehension regarding a lack of resources to achieve the newly established goals.…”

Maintaining Sacred Identities: How Religious Anti‐Consumption Conflicts with Culture

“…Many practices derive from India, which are often informed by Hindu culture. For instance, Zulfiqar and Prasad (2021, 2022) observe how the hierarchies institutionalized through the caste system in modern Pakistan are a remnant of a pre‐partitioned Indian subcontinent. With these realities as the backdrop, a middle‐class consumer culture has blossomed (Ghani, 2014).…”

Local, yet global: Implications of caste for MNEs and international business

“…For example, at nearly 30% of the population in India, the Dalit (untouchable) and Adivasi (Indigenous) Peoples alone number nearly 400 million and face severe inequalities. In Pakistan, where the biraderi system is practiced, major divisions exist between the Zamindars (landowners), the high castes, and the Kammis (service providers), the low castes who are relegated to low-status and low-income jobs like cleaning (Zulfiqar & Prasad, 2022). The caste system has also been a prominent feature of everyday life in Sri Lanka, where three parallel caste systems exist, one among the Sinhalese, one among the Sri Lankan Tamils, and one among the Indian Tamils (Samarakoon, 2022).…”