Effective diversion of surge currents is vital to prevent unwanted damage to sensitive electronics. Among the most successful and efficient strategies relies on a dielectric stimulated arc breakdown mechanism with high permittivity ceramic granules in a spark-gap geometry. Although generally regarded as a self-healing process, substantial energy deposition may occur that, over time, diminishes the ability to withstand repeated electrical assaults. We investigate the susceptibility of lead-magnesium-niobate-lead titanate (PMN-PT) granule microstructure and composition changes following many exposures to high voltage impulses resulting in arc breakdown. Scanning electron microscopy and energy-dispersive spectroscopy mapping reveal a broad range of thermal and mechanical defects entailing thermal reduction of constituent PMN-PT metal ions and recasting due to rapid eruption of volatile species. Additionally, evidence of local melting and microcracking are apparent that can have deleterious impact on the proper function of the granules, namely, the ability to concentrate electric fields across air gaps to establish and sustain discharge pathways. We propose that the localized nature of damage and stochasticity associated with the dielectric stimulated breakdown mechanism may allow granules to maintain functionality provided no permanent conduction paths are established.