Fair Values, Income Measurement, and Bank Analysts' Risk and Valuation Judgments

Abstract

We examine how fair-value-income measurement affects commercial bank equity analysts' risk and value judgments. Normatively, holding information and other underlying economics constant, bank analysts' risk and valuation assessments should distinguish between banks with different risks, but should not depend on how banks measure income. In our experiment, we vary income measurement—full-fair-value (all fair-value changes recognized in income) versus piecemeal-fair-value (some fair-value changes recognized in income, others disclosed in the notes). We also vary interest-rate-risk exposure (exposed versus hedged). We find that bank analysts' risk and value judgments distinguish banks' exposure to interest-rate risk only under full-fair-value-income measurement. Our evidence contributes to research concerned with financial performance reporting, risk, and fair-value accounting by demonstrating that differences in income measurement affect fundamental judgments of specialist analysts. Our findings are striking because they: (1) point toward an important role for measurement and recognition of fair-value gains and losses in income, and (2) suggest that note disclosure is not a substitute for financial-statement recognition (even for professional analysts specializing in banks and working in a context that involves assessment of core operations of a bank). These results should be of interest to accounting standard setters as they evaluate whether to require full-fair-value-income measurement.

The Effect of Adoption of International Public Sector Accounting Standards on Quality of Financial Reports in Public Sector in Kenya

“…For example, studies that examine the association between the decisions usefulness of financial reporting information and the use of fair value (Hirst et al, 2004), between the quality of internal control and the risk of disclosing information and auditor's reports. However, such methods do not by definition give a comprehensive assessment of financial reporting quality.…”

Components of Comprehensive Income and Statement of Changes in Equity: An Analysis of Public Companies’ Reporting Practices in Poland and Germany

“…These studies involved such issues as the impact of the method of presenting comprehensive income on the valuation of the company carried out by financial analysts and on how the results of the company and their volatility is perceived by investors who are not professional financial analysts (Hirst and Hopkins, 1998;Maines and McDaniel, 2000;Hirst, Hopkins and Wahlen, 2004).…”

How Do Fair Value Measurements of Financial Instruments Affect Investments in Banks?

“…Other studies contribute by documenting that the presentation format (Hirst et al, 2004;Clor-Proell et al, 2010) has a significant influence on these results. Clor-Proell et al (2010) document in their experiment that nonprofessional investors assign different reliabilities to fair value valuations based on level 1 and level 3 inputs if these are made salient.…”