‘Failure to Maintain’: A theoretical proposition for a new quality indicator of nurse care rationing for complex older people in hospital

Abstract

Complex older patients represent about half of all acute public hospital admissions in Australia. People with dementia are a classic example of complex older patients, and have been identified to have higher rates of hospital-acquired complications. Complications contribute to poorer patient outcomes, and increase length of stay and cost to hospitals. The care for older people with dementia is complex, and this has been attributed to: their cognitive response to being hospitalised; their limited ability to self-care; and lack of nursing engagement with the family caregiver. Registered nurses can offer simultaneous assessment and intervention to prevent or mitigate hospital-acquired complications. However, it is known that when demand for nursing care exceeds supply, care is prioritised according to acute medical need. Consequently some basic but essential nursing care activities such as patient mobility, communication, skin care, hydration and nutrition are implicitly rationed. This paper offers a theoretical proposition of 'Failure to Maintain' as a conceptual framework to indicate implicit care rationing by nurses. Care rationing contributes to functional and cognitive decline of complex older patients, which then contributes to higher rates of hospital acquired complications. Four key hospital acquired complications: pressure injuries, pneumonia, urinary tract infections and delirium are proposed as measurable indicators of 'Failure to Maintain'. Hospital focus on throughput constrains nurses to privilege predictable, solvable and medically-related procedures and processes that will lead to efficient discharge over patient mobility, communication, skin care, hydration and nutrition. This privileging, also known as implicit rationing, is theoretically and physiologically associated with a rise in the incidence of complications such as pressure injuries, pneumonia, urinary tract infection, and delirium. Complex older patients, including those with dementia, are at higher risk of the complications, therefore should have higher delivery of prophylactic intervention (ie have higher care needs). 'Failure to Maintain' offers a conceptual framework that is inclusive of, and sensitive to, this vulnerable population. Implicit rationing is occurring and it likely contributes to functional and cognitive decline in complex older patients and hospital-acquired complications. However, the lack of patient functional ability data at admission and discharge for hospitalised patients, and lack of usable ward and hospital level nurse staffing and workload data makes it difficult to monitor, understand and improve quality of care. Current research in the fields of acute geriatrics and nursing work environments show promise through enabling multidisciplinary team communication, and facilitating clinical autonomy to provide patient focussed care, and avoid 'Failing to Maintain'. The research field of acute geriatrics can understand and act on the risk modification role of nurses, including controlling for nurse staffing and work env...

The personality profile of the accountable nurse and missed nursing care

“…The finding that personal accountability is negatively linked to missed nursing care, above and beyond scarce resources, supports previous findings (Srulovici & Drach‐Zahavy, ) and suggests that missed nursing care reflects not only a clinical but also an ethical decision‐making process (Bail & Grealish, ). Personal accountability is linked to personal and professional identity and rooted in upbringing, socioeconomic status and culture and in the practices of socialization into the profession and professional experience (Day, ; Krautscheid, ).…”

Constructing definitions of safety risks while nurses care for hospitalised older people: Secondary analysis of qualitative data

“…Unfortunately, the under‐recognition of functional changes as potential signals of acute conditions and general devaluing of older peoples' functional abilities fit with other researchers' findings about care of older people not being viewed as complex (Dahlke & Phinney, ; Baumbusch, Dahlke & Phinney, ; Higgins et al., ; Kjorven et al., ; Parke & Hunter, ). Nurses' constructions of definitions of risks and their lower priority on older people's function so that they could manage risks fit with the theoretical framework—failure to maintain; that framework was developed after reviewing international literature to explain how care rationing for older people ultimately leads to failure to maintain physical and cognitive functioning (Bail & Grealish, ). Similar detrimental outcomes to patients when nurses do not have close surveillance of patients have been identified as failure to rescue (Aiken et al., , ; Clarke & Aiken, ; Schmid, Hoffman, Happ, Wolf, & DeVita, ).…”

“…Because this secondary analysis did not set out to examine nurses' constructions of their definitions of safety risks, a primary study that had such a focus could have provided a more nuanced perspective. Although the data from this study were collected 5 years ago and in a Canadian context, more current international literature and clinical observation suggest that these findings remain relevant in explaining how nurses are negotiating the challenges with caring for older people in other contexts (Bail & Grealish, ).…”

Hospital outcomes of older people with cognitive impairment: An integrative review

“…These may be considered “intermediate” outcomes, precipitating patient deterioration, for example, CI was associated with mortality only in patients who had at least 1 adverse event in hospital, and dementia associated with mortality only if delirium had occurred . Such adverse clinical events could indicate a “failure to maintain” patients' basic health needs, leading to further deterioration . A better understanding of how CI precipitates these events, and what can be done to prevent, detect, and reduce their risk, would enable development of better care models and improved patient outcomes.…”