Solvent selection for extractive fermentation for propionic acid was conducted with three systems: Alamine 304‐1 (trilaurylamine) in 2‐octanol, 1‐dodecanol, and Witcohol 85 NF (oleyl alcohol). Among them, the solvent containing 2‐octanol exhibited the highest partition coefficient in acid extraction, but it was also toxic to propionibacteria. The most solvent‐resistant strain among five strains of the microorganism was selected. Solvent toxicity was eliminated via two strategies: entrapment of dissolved toxic solvent in the culture growth medium with vegetable oils such as corn, olive, or soybean oils; or replacement of the toxic 2‐octanol with nontoxic Witcohol 85 NF. The complete recovery of acids from the Alamine 304‐1/Witcohol 85 NF was also realized with vacuum distillation. ©1998 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Biotechnol Bioeng 57: 454‐461, 1998.