Reported are the synthesis and structural characterization of a series of quaternary lithium-alkaline earth metal alumo-silicides and alumo-germanides with the base formula A2LiAlTt2 (A = Ca, Sr, Ba; Tt = Si, Ge). To synthesize each compound, a mixture of the elements with the desired stoichiometric ratio was loaded into a niobium tube, arc welded shut, enclosed in a silica tube under vacuum, and heated in a tube furnace. Each sample was analyzed by powder and single-crystal X-ray diffraction, and the crystal structure of each compound was confirmed and refined from single-crystal X-ray diffraction data. The structures, despite the identical chemical formulae, are different, largely dependent on the nature of the alkaline earth metal. The differing cation determines the structure type—the calcium compounds are part of the TiNiSi family with the Pnma space group, the strontium compounds are isostructural with Na2LiAlP2 with the Cmce space group, and the barium compounds crystallize with the PbFCl structure type in the P4/nmm space group. The anion (silicon or germanium) only impacts the size of the unit cell, with the silicides having smaller unit cell volumes than the germanides.