Exploring Secondary Students’ Conceptions about Fire Using a Two-Tier, True/False, Easy-to-Use Diagnostic Test

Abstract

This article describes the design of a misconception diagnostic test about fire-related phenomena. It proposes a new test format in which a certainty-measuring tier has been integrated into each of the true/false response choices. This format is argued to be easier for teachers to use than the increasingly popular three-tier format. First, we review the available literature about misconception diagnostic tests and then literature about firerelated misconceptions. We then describe the design process of the test, which was preceded by an interview phase. We then describe its administration to 221 secondary school students. We finally present, in an explorative and accessible manner, the results that were obtained. These results support the existence of previously recorded misconceptions, but also bring certain nuances to some of their previous interpretations. They also support the hypothesis according to which some misconceptions are presumed to be more widespread than they truly are. Conclusive remarks are formulated about the benefits of the use of our-and othermisconception diagnostic tests.

Enhancing pupils’ understanding via discussion based POE method

“…As a result of their study,Indriyani et al (2021) used the POE-DE model to eliminate students' misconceptions and stated that when used together with inquiry-based teaching activities, students' misconceptions were reduced. It is possible to say that the current research findings also show parallelism with previous similar researches, such asFuadi et al (2020),Potvin et al (2015),Banawi et al (2019),Coştu et al (2012),Astiti et al (2020), Arfiani, (2017,Abdullah et al, (2017), andAyvacı (2013) studies.…”

Toward a durable prevalence of scientific conceptions: Tracking the effects of two interfering misconceptions about buoyancy from preschoolers to science teachers

“…It can be considered higher when a person succeeds more often at congruent/intuitive tasks and fails more often at incongruent/counterintuitive ones. We can also hypothesize that adherence could be evaluated by the feeling of certainty that a learner has towards each possible conception (Hemmerich, Van Voorhis, & Wiley, 2016;Potvin, Skelling-Desmeules, & Sy, 2015).…”

An Analysis of Graduate Students’ Conceptual Understanding in Heat and Temperature (H&T) Using Three-Tier Diagnostic Test

“…Various instruments have been created and utilized by researchers to diagnose misconceptions. Like interviews [9], multiple choice [10], multipletier diagnostic such as two-tier tests [11] - [13] and three-tier tests [14] - [16]. Multiple choice tests are the best alternative for diagnosing large numbers of student misconceptions.…”