Exploring perceived control in domestic electricity demand-side response

Abstract

Research into consumer acceptance of domestic electricity demand-side response (DSR) highlights loss of personal control as a key concern. This UK focus group study explored people's perceived control in relation to home energy use and DSR. Three DSR offerings were discussed: fixed and dynamic time of use (TOU) pricing and direct load control. Participants' main motivations for control were costs, comfort, time/flexibility and autonomy. The majority viewed a fixed TOU tariff as increasing personal control, particularly over costs. Dynamic TOU pricing divided opinion, with some perceiving more control over costs, while others were concerned about ease of use, requirement for automation, predictability and flexibility. Almost everyone saw direct load control as reducing their control, although some framed this only in terms of control over appliances, while others were concerned about their overall autonomy. Implications for future research and the design, targeting and communication of DSR products are discussed.

Scripting, control, and privacy in domestic smart grid technologies: Insights from a Danish pilot study

“…Identity, control, freedom and self-determination are vital ingredients of a home (Blunt & Dowling, 2006). Studies have demonstrated that remote control had a negative impact on the sense of control of householders over their homes (Fell, Shipworth, Huebner & Elwell, 2014).…”

Smart grids and households: how are household consumers represented in experimental projects?

“…In agreement with the findings of Strengers (2013), our study finds no consensus among engineers and developers of the energy sector as to the scripts of automation and control in smart grid households. A previous study on people's views on remote control (RC) and variable prices based on focus groups has shown that RC can have an effect on the sense of control that consumers have over their home (Fell et al, 2014).…”

The DSR Scheme in the Capacity Market of Industrial Enterprises in Poland—Participation Determinants

“…The scheme also allows an automatic injection of on-site renewable energy sources as appropriate [31]. The research of smart metering programs in the UK by Fell et al (2014) [32] indicates that consumer acceptance of domestic electricity demand-side response (DSR) highlights the loss of personal control as a critical concern.…”