Explaining Support for Sectarian Terrorism in Pakistan: Piety, Maslak and Sharia

Abstract

Abstract:In the discourse around sectarian violence in Pakistan, two concerns are prominent. The first is the contention that piety, or the intensity of Muslim religious practice, predicts support for sectarian and other forms of Islamist violence. The second is the belief that personal preferences for some forms of sharia also explain such support. As I describe herein, scholars first articulated these concerns in the "clash of civilizations" thesis. Subsequent researchers developed them further in the scholarly and policy analytical literatures that explored these linkages through qualitative and quantitative methodologies. I revisit these claims in the particular context of sectarian violence in Pakistan. To do so, I use several questions included in a recent and large national survey of Pakistanis to create indices of both piety and support for three dimensions of sharia. I use these indices as explanatory variables, along with other explanatory and control variables, in a regression analysis of support for sectarian violence, the dependent variable. I find that the piety index and dimensions of sharia support are significant only when district fixed effects are excluded; however, personal characteristics (i.e., the particular school of Islam respondents espouse, ethnicity, several demographics) most consistently predict support for sectarian violence.

Exploring the Potential of Religious Literacy in Pakistani Education

“…However, regional and political trends in the 1970s and 1980s triggered this conflict into activism. Cultural revolution in Iran and Afghan Jihad were the two prominent features, along with the regime of Zia-ul-Haq, which shifted secular concepts into the Islamization of Pakistan (Fair 2015). The empowerment of Islamic groups (mainly Deobandi groups and Wahabism) during this period not only resulted in the power of the Taliban in Afghanistan but also resulted in greater extremism within Pakistani societies.…”

Political Factors and Sectarian Identities in Tribal Areas of Pakistan

“…It is also worth mentioning, that Pakistani politics can be divided into orthodox and moderate political forces that can be further divided into religious and secular forces. Generally considered a non-militant Islamist political party, Deobandi Jamiat Ulema-e-Islami is significantly tied with Deobandi militant groups that provide an opportunity to militant for political patrons (Fair, 2015). Secular political forces in the country have nothing to do with anti-state elements but some religious political forces strongly linked with anti-state elements.…”

“…This attack also organized and mobilized various militant groups across the border. United State invasion in Afghan initiated on 7 th October 2001, many Taliban and Al-Qaeda associated fighters sought refuge in tribal areas of Pakistan (Fair, 2015). That is why, some important places for US national security included tribal belt adjacent to Pak-Afghan border (Markey, 2008).…”

War on Terrorism in Pakistan: Challenges and Strategic Steps

“…The Taliban launched suicide attacks in various parts of Pakistan, especially in Punjab, KPK and Islamabad, in FATA and Swat. Their main purpose is to hit the security forces [Fair 2015]. The main objective is to create fear, create massive victims, and destabilize the whole situation.…”