Explaining medical disputes in Chinese public hospitals: the doctor–patient relationship and its implications for health policy reforms

Abstract

In recent years China has witnessed a surge in medical disputes, including many widely reported violent riots, attacks, and protests in hospitals. This is the result of a confluence of inappropriate incentives in the health system, the consequent distorted behaviors of physicians, mounting social distrust of the medical profession, and institutional failures of the legal framework. The detrimental effects of the damaged doctor-patient relationship have begun to emerge, calling for rigorous study and serious policy intervention. Using a sequential exploratory design, this article seeks to explain medical disputes in Chinese public hospitals with primary data collected from Shenzhen City. The analysis finds that medical disputes of various forms are disturbingly widespread and reveals that inappropriate internal incentives in hospitals and the heavy workload of physicians undermine the quality of clinical encounters, which easily triggers disputes. Empirically, a heavy workload is associated with a larger number of disputes. A greater number of disputes are associated with higher-level hospitals, which can afford larger financial settlements. The resolution of disputes via the legal channel appears to be unpopular. This article argues that restoring a healthy doctor-patient relationship is no less important than other institutional aspects of health care reform.

Records of medical malpractice litigation: a potential indicator of health-care quality in China

“…Over the same period, there appears to have been a deterioration in the general relationship between patients and providers and an increase in medical litigation and violence against health professionals 17 – 21 . There is a need to resolve such issues but data on health-care quality and useful indicators of such quality are rare in China 22 , 23 .…”

Designing Effective Healthcare: Matching Policy Tools to Problems in China

“…The Chinese government has struggled with controlling pharmaceutical costs for nearly two decades and is only now coming to grips with it (Dong et al 1999;He and Qian 2016). To compensate for reduction of government subsidy, the government had allowed hospitals to earn revenues through sale of drugs other than those designated as essential.…”

“…Efforts such as the National Essential Medicine System, though in its early stages, can help reduce expenditure devoted on pharmaceuticals. Users are only just beginning to assert their interests, which often take the form of violence against providers (He and Qian 2016).…”

Continuing violence against medical personnel in China: A flagrant violation of Chinese law

“…Violence against medical personnel needs to be resolved by sustained and innovative healthcare reform (22).…”