In a natural analog study of risks associated with carbon sequestration, impacts of CO 2 on shallow groundwater quality have been measured in a sandstone aquifer in New Mexico, USA. Despite relatively high levels of dissolved CO 2 , originating from depth and producing geysering at one well, pH depression and consequent trace element mobility are relatively minor effects due to the buffering capacity of the aquifer. However, local contamination due to influx of brackish waters in a subset of wells is significant. Geochemical modeling of major ion concentrations suggests that high alkalinity and carbonate mineral dissolution buffers pH changes due to CO 2 influx. Analysis of trends in dissolved trace elements, chloride, and CO 2 reveal no evidence of in situ trace element mobilization. There is clear evidence, however, that As, U, and Pb are locally co-transported into the aquifer with CO 2 -rich brackish water. This study illustrates the role that local geochemical conditions will play in determining the effectiveness of monitoring strategies for CO 2 leakage. For example, if buffering is significant, pH monitoring may not effectively detect CO 2 leakage. This study also highlights potential complications that CO 2 carrier fluids, such as brackish waters, pose in monitoring impacts of geologic sequestration.