Examining the link between integrated management systems and firm performance: do the integration strategies matter?

Abstract

PurposeThis study attempts to examine the performance differences between firms with and without integrated management systems (IMSs), and the impact of three integration strategies (i.e. implementing quality management system (QMS) first, then environmental management system (EMS) (QMS + EMS); implementing EMS first, then QMS (EMS + QMS); implementing QMS and EMS simultaneously (QMS − EMS)) on firm performance to reveal the IMS–performance relationship and provide empirical evidence.Design/methodology/approachTwo panel datasets were collected during 2009–2019. This study used the Mann–Whitney non-parametric test and a sample of 33,155 observations from 4,316 Chinese listed firms to compare the performance differences between the IMS and non-IMS groups through performance indicators. This study also examined the effects of three integration strategies on firm performance using a cross-sectional time-series feasible generalized least squares (FGLS) regression model and a sample of 11,289 observations from 2,037 firms.FindingsThe results show that significant performance differences exist between IMS and non-IMS firms; however, the performance of firms with an IMS is not always better than that of firms without IMS. Furthermore, the simultaneous integration strategy has a positive impact, whereas sequential integration strategies (QMS + EMS and EMS + QMS) negatively affect firm performance. Compared with the EMS + QMS strategies, the QMS + EMS strategies have a more prominent effect on firm performance. Simultaneous strategies are more effective than sequential strategies.Practical implicationsFirms should fully consider the potential benefits and costs associated with the difficulties of IMS implementation and the implementation order of different management systems and the potential effects of the management systems in different conditions. Firms also should try to develop internal capabilities through implementing different integration strategies.Originality/valueBy comparing performance differences between firms with and without IMS, this study enriches the understanding of the performance benefits of IMS implementation in the Chinese context. By examining the impact of integration strategies that follow different sequences on firm performance, this study promotes an in-depth understanding of the integration strategies and their performance implications beyond simple descriptions and also provides new insights into operations strategy models.

Analysis of asset management difficulties observed in Brazilian firms: a study based on expert survey and fuzzy TOPSIS

“…The benefits of integrating management systems are well-documented in the literature (Barbosa et al. , 2022; Wang and Liu, 2023), which supports the standpoint that asset management must be understood, applied strategically and integrated (Alsyouf et al. , 2021; Onyeaso and Johnson, 2006).…”

“…Considering these variables, the joint implementation of the ISO 31000 standard for risk management (ISO, 2018b) and the ISO 55001 can be a fruitful approach for organizations to better manage the risks associated with asset management, as the standard presents requirements and guidelines for establishing an efficient risk management system. The benefits of integrating management systems are well-documented in the literature (Barbosa et al, 2022;Wang and Liu, 2023), which supports the standpoint that asset management must be understood, applied strategically and integrated (Alsyouf et al, 2021;Onyeaso and Johnson, 2006).…”

Greening the Bricks: Unraveling the Impact of Environmental Policy on Firm Performance in Brick Industry of Pakistan

“…Charef (2022) looked at the effect of EMS on Brazilian businesses' environmental sustainability in another study. According to Wang and Liu (2023), businesses using EMS outperformed those without EMS in terms of pollution avoidance, energy conservation, and waste reduction. Some research, meanwhile, has also produced contradictory findings.…”

“…In turn, this enhanced reputation and brand value may well translate into tangible benefits, such as increased sales and a larger share of the market. The evolving landscape of consumer preferences and business practices further underscores the significance of environmental policy for the brick industry in Pakistan (Wang & Liu, 2023). A growing number of consumers and businesses are actively seeking environmentally sustainable products and services.…”

Towards a Sustainable Future: Exploring the Role of Integrated Management Systems in Enhancing Export Competitiveness and Domestic Sales in Textile Industry

“…This is so because it provides a competitive edge to the businesses via the combination of quality management, environmental management, and occupational health and safety (Marinello & Dinicolò, 2019) This integration enables companies to differentiate their products and services in the global market that confers them with a competitive advantage as well as increasing their export potential. For instance, Wang & Liu (2023) found that there was a positive correlation between adoption of IMS and market share of firms implying that adoption of IMS can enhance export performance. The results also indicated that an integrated system had implications for a company's financial performance which means it has impacts on sales or export performance too.…”