Evaluation of the Impact of Rainfall Inputs on Urban Rainfall Models: A Systematic Review

Abstract

Over the past several decades, urban flooding and other water-related disasters have become increasingly prominent and serious. Although the urban rain flood model’s benefits for urban flood simulation have been extensively documented, the impact of rainfall input to model simulation accuracy remains unclear. This systematic review aims to provide structured research on how rain inputs impact urban rain flood model’s simulation accuracy. The selected 48 peer-reviewed journal articles published between 2015 and 2019 on the Web of Science™ database were analyzed by key factors, including rainfall input type, calibration times and verification times. The results from meta-analysis reveal that when a traditional rain measurement was used as the rainfall input, model simulation accuracy was higher, i.e., the Nash–Sutcliffe efficiency coefficient (NSE) of traditional technology for rain measurement was higher than the 0.18 for the new technology rain measurement with respect to flow simulation. In addition, the single-field sub-flood calibration model was better than the multi-field sub-flood calibration model. NSE was higher than 0.14. The precision was better for the verification period; NSE of the calibration value showed a 0.07 higher verification value on average in flow simulation. These findings have certain significance for the development of future urban rain flood models and propose the development direction of the future urban rain flood model. Finally, in view of the rainfall input problem of the urban storm flood model, we propose the future development direction of the urban storm flood model.

Comprehensive performance evaluation of stormwater management measures for sponge city construction: A case study in Gui'an New District, China

“…Yang et al (2020) proposed a new method for urban flood modeling by coupling a one‐dimensional SWMM and a two‐dimensional flood inundation model, proving that the simulation results are reliable. Research shows that the SWMM model is still the most widely used in the model in urban flood simulation (Hu et al, 2020). SWMM is a dynamic precipitation‐runoff simulation model developed by the US EPA.…”

City Flood Disaster Scenario Simulation based on 1D-2D Coupled Rain-flood Model: A Case Study in Luoyang, China

“…where n is the total number of measured data, Si is the simulated water depth for data point i, Oi is the measured water depth for data point i, and is the averaged value of the measured water depth 35 .…”

The Effect of Design Rainfall Patterns on Urban Flooding Based on the Chicago Method

“…According to the Sixth Assessment Report issued by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) [1], the global average temperature in the first two decades of the 21st century was 0.99 • C higher than the 1850-1900 average. Global warming, the increased probability of extreme rainfall [2,3], accelerated urbanization, and an increased amount of impervious surfaces have made urban flooding frequent [4]. For example, on 2012 "7.21", Beijing's extraordinarily heavy rainfall caused 1.602 million people to be affected and led to economic losses amounting to USD 169 million.…”