Evaluating New Urbanist Plans in Post-Katrina Mississippi

Abstract

Immediately following Hurricane Katrina, the Mississippi Governor's Commission for Recovery, Rebuilding and Renewal partnered with the Congress for the New Urbanism to provide teams of planners and designers to work with communities along the coast in preparing rebuilding plans. Following a week-long charrette in October 2005, each coastal community was provided with a rebuilding plan that was intended to be based on the principles of New Urbanism. The initial plans have been followed up with further long-range planning. Two years after Katrina, this paper examines the degree to which New Urbanism has been incorporated into the long-range comprehensive, master and other rebuilding plans developed in the communities along the coast in Harrison County, Mississippi. This study finds that New Urbanist principles were integrated into some community plans, but were largely absent from others. In those that do incorporate the principles, the realities of post-Katrina planning created serious challenges to the feasibility of implementing New Urbanist plans. While the goals of the New Urbanist consultants were to create better communities and regions, these good intentions have primarily failed on the Mississippi Gulf Coast. In many cases, communities felt dissatisfied with their design-based plans because they were not appropriate for the time and place of post-Katrina Mississippi. The paper concludes by offering suggestions on how communities can improve their plans relative to integrating the principles of New Urbanism that can help rebuild better communities, while balancing community priorities for rebuilding.

Evaluation of Local Comprehensive Plans to Vacancy Issue in a Growing and Shrinking City

“…Third, a local comprehensive plan has been employed from various prior studies as an effective measure to assess a community's long-range visions and preparedness for future developments. Starting from early 1990s, many previous studies assessed diverse topics, including natural hazards [32][33][34][35], affordable housing [36], green infrastructure [37], land use pattern [38], new urbanism [39], sustainable development [21,40], smart growth [41], and urban sprawl [42]. These studies, however, have mostly adopted the content analysis method that was generally relying on Kasier et al's plan evaluation approach [43].…”

The Implications of Post Disaster Recovery for Affordable Housing

“…It is also vital that leadership for these design initiatives be initiated by both the federal and the state government (Bathurst, et al 2011). Once these are initiated, it is imperative that communities and local businesses become fully engaged in the evolutionary design processes prior to the disaster (Popkin, 2006;Cowley-Evans, 2009;Talen, 2008).…”

Reconciling Livability and Sustainability

“…The Mississippi Gulf Coast has worked incrementally, since the years following Hurricane Katrina in 2005, to create a more sustainable region. Community planning efforts were initiated immediately after Hurricane Katrina and resulted in initial rebuilding plans for incorporated communities, but these initial plans were focused on urban design visions, making them limited in their scope for long-term implementation (Evans-Cowley and Gough 2009). Then in 2006, the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development provided funds to the Mississippi Development Authority to enable production of longer-term comprehensive planning for each of the eleven cities and three counties on the Mississippi Gulf Coast.…”