Estimating Hourly Beam and Diffuse Solar Radiation in an Alpine Valley: A Critical Assessment of Decomposition Models

Abstract

Accurate solar radiation estimates in Alpine areas represent a challenging task, because of the strong variability arising from orographic effects and mountain weather phenomena. These factors, together with the scarcity of observations in elevated areas, often cause large modelling uncertainties. In the present paper, estimates of hourly mean diffuse fraction values from global radiation data, provided by a number (13) of decomposition models (chosen among the most widely tested in the literature), are evaluated and compared with observations collected near the city of Bolzano, in the Adige Valley (Italian Alps). In addition, the physical factors influencing diffuse fraction values in such a complex orographic context are explored. The average accuracy of the models were found to be around 27% and 14% for diffuse and beam radiation respectively, the largest errors being observed under clear sky and partly cloudy conditions, respectively. The best performances were provided by the more complex models, i.e., those including a predictor specifically explaining the radiation components' variability associated with scattered clouds. Yet, these models return non-negligible biases. In contrast, the local calibration of a single-equation logistical model with five predictors allows perfectly unbiased estimates, as accurate as those of the best-performing models (20% and 12% for diffuse and beam radiation, respectively), but at much smaller computational costs.

Detecting Snowfall Events over Mountainous Areas Using Optical Imagery

“…Water 2018, 10, x FOR PEER REVIEW 13 of 15 metamorphism process is controlled by solar radiation. Over mountainous areas, the distribution of solar radiation is affected by topography, including elevation, slope, and aspect [39], which affect the snow accumulation and snowmelt owing to the different radiation and energy balances. Therefore, snow distribution is controlled by the terrain in an alpine watershed [40].…”

Improved estimation of global solar radiation over rugged terrains by the disaggregation of Satellite Applications Facility on Land Surface Analysis data (LSA SAF)

“…Among the numerous decomposition models proposed in the literature (Bertrand et al, 2015), the model of Skartveit et al (1998) is used. This model is among the most widespread and has recently been found to be one of the most efficient in a comparison with 13 other models for a highly rugged area near Bolzano (northern Italy) (Laiti et al, 2018). The model is based on three main input predictors: the solar zenith angle, the clearness index and a temporal variability index (hourly in the original model and semi-hourly in ERAD).…”

High-Resolution Observations of Transport and Exchange Processes in Mountainous Terrain

“…Individual components of the radiation balance are typically made with high-quality, carefully calibrated pyranometers and pyrgeometers. The radiation balance in mountainous regions is complicated by a range of factors including heterogeneity of surface radiative properties, roughness elements covering a range of scales, non-uniform aerosol distributions, different vegetation covers, as well as reduced and complex sky view factors and extended shadowing [67]. These different factors may lead to surface radiation balances that differ greatly from flat homogeneous terrain [63].…”