Error patterns in Portuguese students’ addition and subtraction calculation tasks

Abstract

Purpose-The purpose of this descriptive study is to investigate why some elementary children have difficulties mastering addition and subtraction calculation tasks. Design/methodology/approach-The researchers have examined error types in addition and subtraction calculation made by 697 Portuguese students in elementary grades. Each student completed a written assessment of mathematical knowledge. A system code (e.g. FR = failure to regroup) has been used to grade the tests. A reliability check has been performed on 65 per cent randomly selected exams. Findings-Data frequency analyses reveal that the most common type of error was miscalculation for both addition (n = 164; 38.6 per cent) and subtraction (n = 180; 21.7 per cent). The second most common error type was related to failure to regroup in addition (n = 74; 17.5 per cent) and subtraction (n = 139; 16.3 per cent). Frequency of error types by grade level has been provided. Findings from the hierarchical regression analyses indicate that students' performance differences emerged as a function of error types which indicated students' types of difficulties. Research limitations/implications-There are several limitations of this study: the use of a convenient sample; all schools were located in the northern region of Portugal; the limited number of problems; and the time of the year of assessment. Practical implications-Students' errors suggested that their performance in calculation tasks is related to conceptual and procedural knowledge and skills. Error analysis allows teachers to better understand the individual performance of a diverse group and to tailor instruction to ensure that all students have an opportunity to succeed in mathematics. Social implications-Error analysis helps teachers uncover individual students' difficulties and deliver meaningful instruction to all students. Originality/value-This paper adds to the international literature on error analysis and reinforces its value in diagnosing students' type and severity of math difficulties.

Misconceptions and Associated Errors in the Learning of Mathematics Place Value in South African Primary Schools: A Literature Review

“…The second common type of error was miscalculation for both addition and subtraction. The third most common error type was related to the failure to regroup in addition and subtraction (Watson, Loes, Oliveira & Judge, 2018).…”

Mathematics Errors in Elementary School: A Meta-Synthesis Study

“…Result of the research showed that in general, third grade students made errors in calculation procedure, such as addition [8]. Additionally, there were also errors made by students in common problems, especially in addition and substraction calculation [10].…”

Learning Designs for the Addition and Subtraction of Two-Digit Numbers based on Realistic Mathematics Education Principles Using Snakes and Ladders Game

“…Then, according to Watson et al (2018), students often make mistakes systematically and consistently when calculating addition and subtraction of numbers; the students subtracted a smaller number from a larger number. This is also evidenced by the results of the secondgrade student test in one of the elementary schools in Bandung, where there were 21 out of 30 students who were still unable to add and subtract two numbers correctly.…”