Enhancing students' HOTS in laboratory educational activity by using concept map as an alternative assessment tool

Abstract

Educational transformation in the 21st century demands in-depth knowledge and understanding in order to promote the development of higher-order thinking skills (HOTS). However, the most commonly reported problem with respect to developing a knowledge of chemistry is poor mastery of basic concepts. Chemistry laboratory educational activities are shown to be less effective in developing an optimum conceptual understanding and HOTS among students. One factor is a lack of effective assessment and evaluation tools. Therefore, the primary focus of this study is to explore concept maps as an assessment tool in order to move students' thinking skills to a higher level during laboratory learning activities. An embedded mixed method design is used in this study, which has also employed a pre-experimental research design. This design triangulates quantitative and qualitative data, which are combined to strengthen the findings. A low-directed concept mapping technique, convergence scoring method, and pre-post laboratory concept map were used in this study. An electrolysis HOTS test was used as the research instrument in order to measure the level of student achievement with respect to high-level questions. In addition, the thought process that is involved when students construct concept maps has been explored and studied in detail by utilising a think-aloud protocol. Results showed a positive development towards understanding and higher level thinking skills in students with respect to electrolysis concepts learned through chemistry laboratory activities. An investigation of the students' thinking processes showed that high-achieving students were more capable of giving a content-based explanation of electrolysis and engaged in monitoring activities more often while building a concept map. Nonetheless, all categories of students managed to show a positive increase in the activities of explanation and monitoring during the construction of concept maps after they were exposed to the assessment tool in the laboratory learning activities. In conclusion, the assessment activity using concept maps in laboratory learning activities has a positive impact on students' understanding and stimulates students to increase their HOTS.

Concept cartoon in problem-based learning : A systematic literature review analysis

“…This statement is aligned with Balim et al (2016) who have said that problem-based learning, generally used in higher education, requires students to use higher order thinking skills in learning environments. In fact, secondary science students also experience difficulties in visualizing the concept of science as long as the science concept is an abstract nature of topic (Akani, 2017;Ghani, Ibrahim, Yahaya & Surif, 2017). In order to use effectively for secondary students, concept cartoons can be integrated to problem-based learning environment as it can provide alternative views, help students to visualize and solve the problem (Balim et al, 2016).…”

The Use of Edutainment in Promoting Higher Order Thinking Skills in ESL Writing among Malaysian University Students

“…Knowledge, comprehension and application which are the first three levels in Bloom's taxonomy are categorized as lower level of thinking skills that covers basic recognition of these domains. Conversely, the last three levels which are analyse, synthesise and evaluate foster the learning performance of the students that require them to utilize higher order thinking skills (Ghani, Ibrahim, Yahaya & Surif, 2017). This is supported by Singh et al (2018) in their study on which emphasized on the utmost contribution by the teachers in incorporating HOTS in 21 st century learning process in classroom activities.…”

A New Assessment of Hocs-Oriented Learning for Students’ Higher-Order Thinking Abilities by Marzano’s Taxonomy

“…To cultivate students' founding of HOCS, more challenges exist with students' textual designs. As a dynamic learning goal in the 21st century, many educators have pointed that HOCS-oriented learning becomes a meaningful development to find out students' constructions of cognitive knowledge and global competitiveness (Ghani et al, 2017). Innovative learning, critical thinking and problem-solving are accepted as three dominant constituents of the context with the guidance of students' HOCS development in chemistry education (Danczak et al, 2017;Ghani et al, 2017).…”