Enhancing Productivity: The Role of Management Practices

Abstract

There is no doubt that management practices are linked to the productivity and performance of a company. However, research findings are mixed. This paper provides a multi-disciplinary review of the current evidence of such a relationship and offers suggestions for further exploration. We provide an extensive review of the literature in terms of research findings from studies that have been trying to measure and understand the impact that individual management practices and clusters of management practices have on productivity at different levels of analysis. We focus our review on Operations Management (OM) and Human Resource Management (HRM) practices as well as joint applications of these practices. In conclusion, we can say that taken as a whole, the research findings are equivocal. Some studies have found a positive relationship between the adoption of management practices and productivity, some negative and some no association whatsoever. We believe that the lack of universal consensus on the effect of the adoption of complementary management practices might be driven either by measurement issues or by the level of analysis. Consequently, there is a need for further research. In particular, for a multi-level approach from the lowest possible level of aggregation up to the firm-level of analysis in order to assess the impact of management practices upon the productivity of firms.

How Managers Talk about their Consumption of Popular Management Concepts: Identity, Rules and Situations

“…Reports of increased organizational performance following concept adoption (cf. Hammer and Champy, ; Siebers et al ., ; Womack, Jones and Roos, ), as well as the international diffusion and transient popularity of concepts (Abrahamson and Fairchild, ), sparked an extensive research interest over the last few decades (Clark, ; Heusinkveld, Sturdy and Werr, ).…”

Performance, labour flexibility and migrant workers in hotels: An establishment and departmental level analysis

“…These provide exceptionally detailed data on the relationships between labour and employment practices and performance, rather than relying on subjective estimates by managers, or on annual average returns. Controlling for heterogeneity by examining a single hotel company is important because management practices which target productivity and performance enhancement are likely to be firm specific (Wall and Wood 2005;Siebers et al 2007). Focussing on a single company allows a measure of control for the institutional environment within which individual hotels (and departments within these) manage employment practices and overall performance.…”

Human Resource Expenditure And Productivity Of Universities In Nigeria

“…OLS technique and Chi-square were used to analyze data. Siebers, et al (2008) carried out a literature review of research findings of past studies conducted on human resource management practices and productivity. Their study revealed that research findings on this subject by scholars were mixed.…”