This study proposes new data on the rare pyroxene, variety violane, sampled from its type locality, Praborna manganese deposit, near Saint Marcel (Val d’Aosta, Italy). Violane is very appreciated as a gemstone for its different hues of violet-blue color and is characterized by its diopsidic or omphacitic composition. To assess the possible causes of color, electron-probe microanalysis (EMPA) and laser-ablation inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (LA–ICP–MS) were used to establish the chemical composition. Raman and Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy, ideal for the non-destructive analysis, identified the different present phases directly on gemstone. Raman and FTIR spectra highlighted the presence, in the same sample, of diopside and omphacite showing almost inappreciable violet hue difference. The two minerals were easily differentiated by microprobe analyses and showed a compositional heterogeneity not linked to the different colors. The best way to detect the color-causing elements in microcrystalline violanes resulted in the analysis of trace elements and their quantification. An enrichment of Ti and Li characterizes darker violet omphacite and that of V and rare-earth elements (REE) the lilac-lavender or light violet-blue diopside. In general, our results led us to say that the color changes, previously proposed as due to Mn both in divalent and trivalent oxidation state, may be controlled by trace elements or by concentration of minor elements, such as Fe, and their oxidation state. REE patterns showed a negative anomaly of Ce that could be ascribed to the variation of the oxygen chemical potential occurring in the ore. The new data, combined with previous results, may provide new constrains on the processes that generated the Mn-rich deposit of Praborna.