Abstract:This article is aimed at organisations and researchers to urge them to adopt more systemic ways to deal with energy justice issues in renewable energy projects being built around the world to help meet the United Nations Sustainable Development Goal (UNSDG) 7. It will focus on solar and wind farms. While these projects positively contribute towards achieving UNSDG 7 (viz., affordable clean energy), they have also created a variety of justice issues, which need to be addressed. While measures have been taken mo… Show more
“…It is a crucial commonality identified in this study. Although renewables contribute towards achieving SDG 7 for affordable and clean energy for all, as mentioned by Sankaran and McIntyre-Mills [17], they have also created different justice issues that need to be addressed.…”
Section: A Brief Discussion On Justice and Sustainability In The Ener...mentioning
confidence: 99%
“…According to Scheidel et al [8] (p. 594), 'sustainability transitions can ironically trigger a whole new set of unsustainabilities and conflicts'. Although using renewable sources might promote a greener, healthier, safer, and likely cheaper global energy system [16], it might camouflage justice issues associated with-usually large-size-renewable electric power projects [17]. Dunlap and Marin [18] listed at least two dimensions of (un)sustainable renewables: those related to high raw materials requirements for low-carbon power plants and those related to land use change for more extensive infrastructures than commonly imagined.…”
Section: Background-energy Transition and Socio-ecological Controversiesmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Furthermore, inspired by the Ilich discourse, de Majo [73] suggests that within the idea of commons lies the possibility of promoting environmental sustainability globally, connecting the universe of collective properties to ecological thought. Meanwhile, Sankaran and McIntyre-Mills [17] add the ecological democracy dimension. Some authors have stimulated the discussion about the collective, democratic, and decentralised use of NCREs as a means to a sustainable future [66,71,74].…”
Section: Citizen Engagement and Energy Commonsmentioning
Chile and Brazil have been historically recognised in South America for having a high share of renewable sources in their primary energy matrices. Furthermore, in the last two decades, aligned with the global efforts to conduct a sustainable energy transition, both countries have experienced a successful introduction of nonconventional renewable energy for power production. Nevertheless, some experiences with renewable sources have been demonstrated to be not entirely societally and environmentally friendly, as some local human communities and ecosystems are threatened, and conflicts have emerged, regardless of low-emission technology. Using the cases of Chile and Brazil, we aim to explore the socio-ecological dimension of sustainable energy transition―which has sometimes been ignored. We analyse the controversies regarding renewable energy and the emergence of socio-ecological conflicts through the principles of justice in transitions. Critical renewable conflicting power projects are identified using the Atlas of Environmental Justice’s database. Considering those experiences, we believe that reinforcing decision-making processes should be in synergy with identifying new alternatives to develop energy in both countries. Placing justice approaches at the centre of public policies is imperative to developing sustainable policies in the future.
“…It is a crucial commonality identified in this study. Although renewables contribute towards achieving SDG 7 for affordable and clean energy for all, as mentioned by Sankaran and McIntyre-Mills [17], they have also created different justice issues that need to be addressed.…”
Section: A Brief Discussion On Justice and Sustainability In The Ener...mentioning
confidence: 99%
“…According to Scheidel et al [8] (p. 594), 'sustainability transitions can ironically trigger a whole new set of unsustainabilities and conflicts'. Although using renewable sources might promote a greener, healthier, safer, and likely cheaper global energy system [16], it might camouflage justice issues associated with-usually large-size-renewable electric power projects [17]. Dunlap and Marin [18] listed at least two dimensions of (un)sustainable renewables: those related to high raw materials requirements for low-carbon power plants and those related to land use change for more extensive infrastructures than commonly imagined.…”
Section: Background-energy Transition and Socio-ecological Controversiesmentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Furthermore, inspired by the Ilich discourse, de Majo [73] suggests that within the idea of commons lies the possibility of promoting environmental sustainability globally, connecting the universe of collective properties to ecological thought. Meanwhile, Sankaran and McIntyre-Mills [17] add the ecological democracy dimension. Some authors have stimulated the discussion about the collective, democratic, and decentralised use of NCREs as a means to a sustainable future [66,71,74].…”
Section: Citizen Engagement and Energy Commonsmentioning
Chile and Brazil have been historically recognised in South America for having a high share of renewable sources in their primary energy matrices. Furthermore, in the last two decades, aligned with the global efforts to conduct a sustainable energy transition, both countries have experienced a successful introduction of nonconventional renewable energy for power production. Nevertheless, some experiences with renewable sources have been demonstrated to be not entirely societally and environmentally friendly, as some local human communities and ecosystems are threatened, and conflicts have emerged, regardless of low-emission technology. Using the cases of Chile and Brazil, we aim to explore the socio-ecological dimension of sustainable energy transition―which has sometimes been ignored. We analyse the controversies regarding renewable energy and the emergence of socio-ecological conflicts through the principles of justice in transitions. Critical renewable conflicting power projects are identified using the Atlas of Environmental Justice’s database. Considering those experiences, we believe that reinforcing decision-making processes should be in synergy with identifying new alternatives to develop energy in both countries. Placing justice approaches at the centre of public policies is imperative to developing sustainable policies in the future.
“… Source : Adapted from https://earthbound.report/2018/01/15/elinor-ostroms-8-rules-for-managing-the-commons and extends Sankaran and McIntyre‐Mills, 2022, McIntyre‐Mills, J. J, Makaulule M, Lethole, P., Pitsoane, E., Arko‐Achemfuor, A, and Wirawan, R, and Widianingsih, I. (2022) Ecocentric living: a way forward towards zero carbon.…”
Section: Tbl and Well‐being Indicators To Map Turning Points For The ...mentioning
confidence: 99%
“…Engage, facilitate and map Elinor Ostrom's eight principles for managing the commons. Source : United Nations Sustainable Development Goals ( https://www.globalgoals.org/take‐action/?gclid=Cj0KCQjw1OmoBhDXARIsAAAYGSGR9cAdQKswJJc75nARQkik15PnHI3OiJfB18qmfqEKgYOmPk0xJE4aAi7hEALw_wcB), “Together we can grow” (McIntyre‐Mills et al, 2022; Sankaran & McIntyre‐Mills, 2022; Wirawan et al, 2023) in which the design is discussed with reference to Ostrom's 8 principles. [Colour figure can be viewed at wileyonlinelibrary.com]…”
Section: Transformative Axiology Based On Critical Systemic Praxis: R...mentioning
This paper explores the concept of community engagement, aligned with President Jokowi's mission to promote social enterprises, as a means to support the development of a re‐generative circular green economy in Tarumajaya, West Java. The primary focus is on enhancing farming, fishing, and forestry activities with villagers. The Covid‐19 pandemic presented significant challenges for the villagers, particularly in marketing their goods, resulting in financial hardships and an increased vulnerability to debt traps, particularly affecting women. Additionally, a major obstacle to achieving regenerative living is the limited access to land, with approximately 80% of the villagers either landless or owning small plots. Moreover, fishing restrictions imposed by the military to protect the Citarum River have further curtailed access to common grazing land for cattle. Preliminary analysis indicates that adopting intensive farming methods, such as rabbit breeding, mushroom cultivation, and fertiliser production, holds promise for reducing the community's carbon footprint. Overcoming these challenges and mapping pathways towards regenerative living are central objectives of this case study, providing insights and practical strategies to foster sustainable economic and environmental progress in Tarumajaya. Key components of the approach include finding markets for village products, extending access to common resources such as rivers, forests, and hillside terraces to villagers, and providing mentorship to women for supporting their small enterprises. The ongoing partnership with the village involves a community of practice consisting of universities and nongovernmental organisations, while private sector entities, including a gas company and tea and coffee plantations, are engaged in negotiations with the village head to secure additional land access. This study highlights the combination of challenges arising from the lack of access to common resources, limited market opportunities, and the influence of predatory financial institutions during the pandemic. By working closely with the villagers, the case study aims to identify opportunities and support the transition towards a green circular economy that moves away from business as usual and promotes regenerative living.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.
