Emotion Processing in Chimeric Faces: Hemispheric Asymmetries in Expression and Recognition of Emotions

Abstract

Since the discovery of facial asymmetries in emotional expressions of humans and other primates, hypotheses have related the greater left-hemiface intensity to right-hemispheric dominance in emotion processing. However, the difficulty of creating true frontal views of facial expressions in two-dimensional photographs has confounded efforts to better understand the phenomenon. We have recently described a method for obtaining three-dimensional photographs of posed and evoked emotional expressions and used these stimuli to investigate both intensity of expression and accuracy of recognizing emotion in chimeric faces constructed from only left- or right-side composites. The participant population included 38 (19 male, 19 female) African-American, Caucasian, and Asian adults. They were presented with chimeric composites generated from faces of eight actors and eight actresses showing four emotions: happiness, sadness, anger, and fear, each in posed and evoked conditions. We replicated the finding that emotions are expressed more intensely in the left hemiface for all emotions and conditions, with the exception of evoked anger, which was expressed more intensely in the right hemiface. In contrast, the results indicated that emotional expressions are recognized more efficiently in the right hemiface, indicating that the right hemiface expresses emotions more accurately. The double dissociation between the laterality of expression intensity and that of recognition efficiency supports the notion that the two kinds of processes may have distinct neural substrates. Evoked anger is uniquely expressed more intensely and accurately on the side of the face that projects to the viewer's right hemisphere, dominant in emotion recognition.

The role of neuroimaging for the diagnosis and treatment of anxiety disorders

“…In comparison, right amygdaloid activity was stronger when positive facial expressions were evaluated [54]. Others have found emotional expressions of happiness, fear, and sadness but not anger are recognized more efficiently in the right versus the left hemiface [55]. This notion is consistent with findings of exaggerated left but not right amygdala response to masked faces in depressed subjects [56].…”

Asymmetry of the Face in Orthodontic Patients

“…20,21 Most studies suggest that the left side of the face is more expressive of emotions. [22][23][24] Such a functional asymmetry in facial expression may have some relationship to the dimensional balance between the left and the right hemiface.…”

Consistent left gaze bias in processing different facial cues

“…Alternatively, considering that the left and right hemiface can transmit the same type of facial cues in different intensity and/or speed (e.g. evoked anger is expressed more intensely in our right hemiface; Indersmitten and Gur 2003), the LGB could be actively engaged in face processing for the accurate and efficient detection or recognition of specific facial cues.…”