Effort-reward imbalance and quality of life of healthcare workers in military hospitals: a cross-sectional study

Abstract

BackgroundTaiwan’s National Defense Bureau has been merging its hospitals and adjusting hospital accreditation levels since the beginning of 2006. These changes have introduced many stressors to the healthcare workers in these hospitals. This study investigates the association between job stress, psychological morbidity and quality of life in healthcare workers in three military hospitals.MethodsWe posted surveys to 1269 healthcare workers in three military hospitals located in southern Taiwan. The surveys included the General Health Questionnaire (GHQ), the World Health Organization Quality of Life Questionnaire (WHOQOL-BREF), and the Effort-Reward Imbalance (ERI) Questionnaire. High effort-reward (ER) ratio and overcommitment were defined when scores fell into the upper tertile of the total distribution.ResultsThe survey was completed by 791 healthcare workers. On average, women reported a higher ERI than men. High ERI was associated with younger age, higher psychological morbidity, and poor physical and psychological QOL domains in this population. High ER ratio and high overcommitment were associated with psychological morbidity and poor QOL in both sexes. However, high ER ratio was not significantly associated with the social QOL domain in either sexes or the physical QOL domain in males.ConclusionsThere was a clear association between ERI and QOL in the healthcare workers in the military hospitals under reorganization and accreditation in this study. We found ER ratio and overcommitment to be suitable indicators of job stress.

Work stress and quality of life in persons with disabilities from four European countries: the case of spinal cord injury

“…The consistent findings concerning the ERI model are in line with those reported from studies on general working populations. For instance, previous studies demonstrated that a mismatch between effort and reward at work is associated with reduced QoL among general working populations [46] and in different occupational groups such as nurses [47], health care workers [48,49], or employees from a manufacturing plant [50]. Our findings provide partial support for the hypothesis that low job control is associated with reduced QoL.…”

A systematic review of effort‐reward imbalance among health workers

“…Particularly, a study of Li et al, showed men scoring higher in effort and overcommitment but lower in reward than women . A number of studies also highlighted the role of job position to the ERI, where nurses are likely to have a higher imbalance in effort‐reward (ER) compared with physicians and registered nurses showed higher ER ratios than nurse technicians . In addition, a few studies have identified an association between ERI and work stress and job dissatisfaction leading directly to the health problems such as cardiovascular risk and medical conditions, including type II diabetes, as well as psychiatric disorders and symptoms …”

Factors associated with health-related quality of life among injection drug users at methadone clinics in Taipei, Taiwan

“…As compared with other populations in Taiwan, IDUs had lower HRQOL scores than obese patients, 14 health care workers, 24 and factory workers. 25 Also, IDUs who had injected drugs > or < 10 years had poor HRQOL compared with other populations in Taiwan.…”