In this paper, we study the performance of energy-efficient resource allocation schemes for multi-cell OFDMA networks based on Game Theory. These schemes have been evaluated in the literature; however, the evaluations have been done under different system models and simulation environments, making a fair comparison unfeasible. Hence, we first develop an appropriate system model for comparison. Then, we analyze the implementation of the selected schemes under constraints introduced by the proposed system model. Finally, throughout extensive numerical simulations on a realistic environment, we evaluate the performance and tradeoffs between energy efficiency, throughput, outage probability and fairness, highlighting the need for some scheme that improves the outage probability and the throughput maintaining high energy efficiency.