Efficiency of selection for body weight in a cooperative village breeding program of Menz sheep under smallholder farming system

Abstract

We evaluated the efficiency of selection for body weight in a cooperative village breeding program for Menz sheep of Ethiopia under smallholder farming system. The design of the program involved organizing villagers in a cooperative breeding group to implement selective breeding of their sheep. The program was jump-started through a one-time provision of elite rams from a central nucleus flock, but subsequent replacement rams were selected from within the village flocks. We also evaluated body weight trends in a village where cooperative breeding was not implemented and individual farmers managed their flocks under traditional breeding practices. Under traditional breeding practices, genetic progress over 8 years either stagnated or declined in all the weights recorded. In the cooperative villages, selection differentials of 2.44 and 2.45 kg were achieved in 2010 and 2011 selection seasons, respectively. Birth weight, 3-month weight and 6-month weight increased, respectively, by 0.49, 2.29 and 2.46 kg in the third-generation lambs over the base generation. Improved rams supplied from the central nucleus flock gave an initial genetic lift of 14.4% in the 6-month weight. This was higher than the gain achieved from selection in the village flocks, which was 5.2%. Our results showed that village-based genetic improvement in body weights under smallholder conditions could be feasible if appropriate designs are adopted and that commencing with elite central nucleus rams help jump-start village-based programs.

Community‐based livestock breeding programmes: essentials and examples

“…Indigenous knowledge of the community was considered at each phase of the project (Gizaw et al . ; Haile et al . ).…”

“…; Gizaw et al . ). For this reason, efforts in the screening of animals for the initial nucleus are crucial.…”

“…Early years are crucial for farmers and stakeholders alike who will be eager to see success. Visible results in the short time are difficult to achieve in within breed selection programmes unless the initial nucleus is outstanding Gizaw et al 2014a). For this reason, efforts in the screening of animals for the initial nucleus are crucial.…”

Economic evaluation of progeny-testing and genomic selection schemes for small-sized nucleus dairy cattle breeding programs in developing countries

“…Small-sized programs may provide the means for improving local genetic resources in countries where infrastructure for large-size pedigree registration and milk recording are lacking (Kariuki et al, 2014). From the literature, it is well known that small-sized breeding programs can create significant genetic gains (Okeno et al, 2010b;Gizaw et al, 2014;Kariuki et al, 2014). However, successful implementation of such programs will ultimately be determined by their economic results.…”

Editorial: Agroecology for producing goods and services in sustainable animal farming systems

“…Changing a system also requires a deeper understanding of the attitudes of farmers. For instance, Gizaw et al (2014) show that collective breeding programs in Ethiopia lead to genetic improvement that cannot be achieved through individual efforts of smallholder farmers, and that the integration of farmers' own criteria (pelvic width, body length, color, horn) to select rams does not affect the program efficiency but makes it socially acceptable. Latawiec et al (2014) review the main constraints for sustainable intensification of cattle grazing in Brazil in terms of productivity, pasture management, socio-economic impacts and climate change mitigation.…”