Efficacy of a Web-Based Guided Recommendation Service for a Curated List of Readily Available Mental Health and Well-Being Mobile Apps for Young People: Randomized Controlled Trial

Abstract

BackgroundMental disorders are highly prevalent for the people who are aged between 16 and 25 years and can permanently disrupt the development of these individuals. Easily available mobile health (mHealth) apps for mobile phones have great potential for the prevention and early intervention of mental disorders in young adults, but interventions are required that can help individuals to both identify high-quality mobile apps and use them to change health and lifestyle behavior.ObjectivesThe study aimed to assess the efficacy of a Web-based self-guided app recommendation service (“The Toolbox”) in improving the well-being of young Australians aged between 16 and 25 years. The intervention was developed in collaboration with young adults and consists of a curated list of 46 readily available health and well-being apps, assessed and rated by professionals and young people. Participants are guided by an interactive quiz and subsequently receive recommendations for particular apps to download and use based on their personal goals.MethodsThe study was a waitlist, parallel-arm, randomized controlled trial. Our primary outcome measure was change in well-being as measured by the Mental Health Continuum-Short Form (MHC-SF). We also employed ecological momentary assessments (EMAs) to track mood, energy, rest, and sleep. Participants were recruited from the general Australian population, via several Web-based and community strategies. The study was conducted through a Web-based platform consisting of a landing Web page and capabilities to administer study measures at different time points. Web-based measurements were self-assessed at baseline and 4 weeks, and EMAs were collected repeatedly at regular weekly intervals or ad hoc when participants interacted with the study platform. Primary outcomes were analyzed using linear mixed-models and intention-to-treat (ITT) analysis.ResultsA total of 387 participants completed baseline scores and were randomized into the trial. Results demonstrated no significant effect of “The Toolbox” intervention on participant well-being at 4 weeks compared with the control group (P=.66). There were also no significant differences between the intervention and control groups at 4 weeks on any of the subscales of the MHC-SF (psychological: P=.95, social: P=.42, emotional: P=.95). Repeat engagement with the study platform resulted in a significant difference in mood, energy, rest, and sleep trajectories between intervention and control groups as measured by EMAs (P<.01).ConclusionsThis was the first study to assess the effectiveness of a Web-based well-being intervention in a sample of young adults. The design of the intervention utilized expert rating of existing apps and end-user codesign approaches resulting in an app recommendation service. Our finding suggests that recommended readily available mental health and well-being apps may not lead to improvements in the well-being of a nonclinical sample of young people, but might halt a decline in mood, energy, rest, and sleep.Trial RegistrationAustra...

Proportionate methods for evaluating a simple digital mental health tool

“…In addition, the sample is relatively homogeneous—predominantly white females (the target audience for In Hand was young people aged up to 25 years, so the limited age range was as to be expected). This gender difference is observed in other research of similar tools, 16–18 but whether this is a mHealth usage or research participation bias is not clear.…”

“…As with In Hand , most users rated the help as ‘a little bit’ rather than ‘a lot’, confirming that both these tools have a limited, specific effect and, as would be expected, one mHealth app would not provide all the functions required for overall mental health. 16 …”

Preventive digital mental health interventions for children and young people: a review of the design and reporting of research

“…Calear et al 46 e-couch anxiety and worry (1) ✓ Burckhardt et al 47 Bite Back ✓ ✓ Bannink et al 48 E-health4Uth ✓ Bidargaddi et al 56 The Toolbox ✓ ✓ ✓…”

A School Survey on Use and Knowledge of Apps and Websites for Promoting Mental Wellbeing

“…An implication of the survey findings on how young people understand 'mental wellbeing' is that despite growing evidence that digital technologies can be used to improve mental health among young people (e.g. Bidargaddi et al, 2017;Simons et. al., 2015), a problem may exist as to finding those resources that are likely to be helpful-due to lack of understanding or misconceptions about mental wellbeing.…”