Effects of Diagnostic Work‐Up on Medical Decision‐Making for Canine Urinary Tract Infection: An Observational Study in Danish Small Animal Practices

Abstract

BackgroundClinical signs of urinary tract disease in dogs often lead to prescription of antibiotics. Appropriate diagnostic work‐up could optimize treatment and reduce the risk of inappropriate use of antibiotics.Hypothesis/ObjectivesTo describe and evaluate the impact of diagnostic work‐up on decision to treat (DTT) and choice of antibiotic treatment (COT) for dogs presenting with clinical signs of urinary tract disease.AnimalsOne hundred and fifty‐one dogs presenting to 52 Danish veterinary practices.MethodsProspective, observational study. Clinical signs, diagnostic work‐up, and prescriptions were recorded. Urine samples were submitted to a reference laboratory for quantitative bacterial culture (QBC) and susceptibility testing. The laboratory results were used as reference for assessing the appropriateness of DTT and COT.ResultsIn the majority of dogs, veterinarians performed dipstick (99%), microscopic examination of urine (80%) and bacterial culture (56%). Fifty‐one percent of dogs had urinary tract infection (UTI) based on reference QBC. Appropriate DTT was made for 62% of the dogs, while 36% were over‐prescribed and 2% under‐prescribed. Inappropriate use of second‐line agents was found in 57% of the UTI cases. Performing microscopy—but not culture—significantly impacted DTT (P = 0.039) while no difference was seen in COT (P = 0.67). The accuracy of in‐house microscopy and culture were 64.5 and 77%, respectively. Conclusions and Clinical Importance: Over‐prescription of antibiotics was common among dogs with suspected UTI, regardless of the diagnostic work‐up performed. Test inaccuracy under practice conditions and incoherence between diagnostic test results and decision‐making both explained inappropriate and unnecessary use of antibiotics.

Antimicrobial prescriptions and adherence to prudent use guidelines for selected canine diseases in Switzerland in 2016

“…Similar to previous studies,10 17 63 potentiated aminopenicillins were used more commonly than non-potentiated aminopenicillins to treat sporadic UTI in this cohort, although non-potentiated aminopenicillins are the recommended choice 26 30. The use of non-potentiated aminopenicillins is preferred whenever possible, because the addition of clavulanic acid increases AmpC-mediated resistance to first-generation, second-generation and third-generation cephalosporins 65 66.…”

Transurethral cystoscopy in dogs with recurrent urinary tract infections: Retrospective study (2011‐2018)

“…Diagnosis of UTI relies on history, physical examination, complete urinalysis with sediment examination, and urine culture . Over‐treatment of dogs with subclinical bacteriuria is a frequent, inappropriate decision leading to over‐use of antibiotics …”

The Occurrence of Multidrug Resistant Bacteria in the Urine of Healthy Dogs and Dogs with Cystitis

“…According to Sorensen et al [7], the over-prescription of antibiotics is common in dogs with suspected UTIs, and the use is inappropriate and unnecessary in most cases. Culture and antimicrobial susceptibility testing should be performed to choose the appropriate antibiotic.…”

“…Several bacteria have been isolated, such as Escherichia coli, Staphylococcus spp., Proteus spp., Klebsiella spp., Enterococcus spp., and Streptococcus spp. [2,[4][5][6][7].…”