Effect of Multidisciplinary Case Conferences on Physician Decision Making: Breast Diagnostic Rounds

Abstract

Purpose: To evaluate the utility of multidisciplinary case conferences (MCCs) on physician decision making in benign and malignant breast disease management.Methods: Patients with interesting or challenging diagnostic or management issues were discussed at biweekly diagnostic breast MCCs. Prior to discussion, a clinical summary and intended management plan prior to the MCC was presented. For each case, diagnostic images/histopathology were centrally reviewed after which group discussion achieved a management consensus which was documented prospectively. Initial management plans were compared to the post-MCC consensus. A change in a management plan was defined as a consensus plan different from the pre-MCC plan or no definite plan prior to the MCC.Results: From November 2014 to December 2015, 76 patients (43 malignant and 33 benign diagnoses) were discussed in 19 MCCs. All cases presented resulted in a consensus management recommendation. Thirty-one case discussions (41%) resulted in a changed management plan (20 malignant and 11 benign diagnoses). Management changes included avoidance of immediate surgery (9% of cases), change in the type of surgery (5%), non-invasive investigation to invasive/surgical intervention (7%), and detection of a new suspicious lesion (1%).Conclusion: MCCs had a substantial impact on physician decision making. Management plans changed in 41% of cases presented, the majority due to new/clarified diagnostic information. Presentation of cases at MCCs should be encouraged, especially for challenging diagnostic or management issues regarding malignant or benign breast diagnoses.

Impact of GI Tumor Board on Patient Management and Adherence to Guidelines

“… 9 The proposed strategies for treating 41% of cases were reformed following the NCCN guidelines. 10 The TB had a significant effect on changing 40% of treatment plans and 60% of staging and assessment plans. 11 Another study demonstrated staging modifications or alterations of treatment plans in 60% of patients.…”

The requirements of a specialist breast centre

“…A study in Taiwan that compared those receiving MDT treatment with those without found that MDT intervention significantly increased the breast cancer survival rate [ 100 ]. A population study from a region in Germany suggested there may be evidence of increased mortality if breast cancer patients do not receive guideline compatible treatment [ 101 ]. There are studies that report changes in treatment plans following MDT discussion.…”

Input of Psychosocial Information During Multidisciplinary Team Meetings at Medical Oncology Departments: Protocol for an Observational Study

“…The current literature provides evidence that MDTMs are achieving intended objectives [ 3 , 4 ]. MDTMs lead to significant changes in the way cancer patients are assessed and managed [ 1 , 5 ] and lead to improved outcomes [ 6 - 8 ]. But there are also indications to question the positive impact of MDTMs in oncology settings [ 9 ].…”