The structural chemistry of the solid ion-conducting Li x La 2/3−x/3 TiO 3 (LLTO) is rich with various polymorphs related to atomic segregation. We explored the LLTO reaction pathway from various structurally related precursors (La 2 LiO 3 H, Li 2 TiO 3 , and Li 4 Ti 5 O 12 ), focusing on the effects of LLTO-like structural motifs in precursors using a combination of experimental and computational techniques. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations revealed that the failure of syntheses to produce LLTO below 1300 °C is due to the presence of multiple competing low-energy phases that result in competitive byproduct formation. In all syntheses where T = 1300 °C, LLTO was the sole product; however, varying phase fractions of I4/mcm and P4/nbm polymorphs and double-perovskite P4/mmm can be obtained depending on the synthesis route. This is an unusual result as at 1300 °C, LLTO should only be the ideal cubic Pm-3m perovskite structure, yet there appears to be a memory effect from the different precursors resulting in the unique phase selectivity and stabilization.